Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
14 Senators Decide the Oil Industry, Not Obama, Should Make the Keystone XL Decision
At America’s founding, the Constitution’s framers set up the government with checks and balances to prevent any branch from dictating the direction of the nation without input and participation from all parties that is necessary in a representative democracy. Over the past four years, Republicans have attempted to neuter the Executive Branch through various obstructive measures to assert their dominance over the President from a minority position, and to make governing nearly impossible. Republicans are not really in control because they answer to the corporate world, and of all their masters, the oil industry holds the greatest sway over Republicans, the nation’s energy policy, and if 14 Senators have their way, the President of the United States.
For four years, Republicans have attempted to force President Obama to approve a Canadian oil company’s permit to build a pipeline across America because it is too environmentally dangerous to cross Canada’s frontier. Last week, a State Department report prepared by the oil industry (Koch brothers, ExxonMobil, TransCanada, and BP) claimed the pipeline posed no threat to the environment and Republicans demanded instantaneous Presidential approval to build the pipeline shipping tar to the Gulf Coast on its way to Europe and South America. The oil industry’s appraisal that the pipeline is environmentally friendly is in stark contrast to every environmental scientist in the world that says the pipeline means “game over for Earth’s environment.” For the record, America will get not get any of the refined tar sands, but it did not stop a bipartisan group of Senators who decided that the oil industry, not the President, makes decisions reserved for the Executive Branch and they introduced a bill giving Congress supremacy over the President.
On Monday, in an op/ed a Republican representative, Tim Walberg, perpetuated the mountain of lies John Boehner has repeated over the past two years, and said, “President Obama has run out of excuses to deny job-creating Keystone XL pipeline,” but when coupled with the Senate bill taking control of the Executive branch’s purview the message is blunt; the President will either toe the line and do as he is told, or the oil industry’s surrogates in Congress will seize State Department and presidential power and approve the pipeline themselves. White House spokesman Jay Carney responded to the Senators’ power-grab and informed them that “the approval process for pipelines crossing international borders belongs to the State Department,” but the oil industry and Republicans already knew that and are proceeding according to their masters’ demands.
There are myriad reasons the President can cite for not approving TransCanada’s permit to send Canadian tar sand to refineries on the Gulf Coast, but they are not excuses as Republicans have parroted the past three years. But instead of debunking what Republicans claim are excuses for not approving the ecological disaster-in-waiting, it is easier to cite the Republican and oil industry’s excuses for approving the KeystoneXL pipeline. However, Republicans are remiss to cite the facts surrounding the pipeline, and none lesser than the pipeline is prone to ruptures and the oil is already slated for export to Europe and South America, and that America will not profit or benefit from protecting Canada’s environment.
The Republican excuses for building the pipeline include creating about 35 permanent jobs, enriching the Kochs’ 25% share of tar sand refining, boosting profits for Canada’s oil industry, raising the price of gas by 20 cents/gallon, increasing CO2 emissions to planetary environment destroying levels, jeopardizing water for 20% of the nation’s agriculture and millions of Americans’ drinking water, driving up share prices for John Boehner’s investment in 7 Canadian tar sand companies, spares Canada’s western frontier from ecological disasters, and raises Canada’s standing as a major producer and exporter of fossil fuels. Those excuses for building the pipeline do not acknowledge that KeystoneXL’s construction provides South America and Europe with Canadian oil, gives ConocoPhilips and Koch refineries steady profits for decades, rewards Kochs, ExxonMobil, TransCanada, and BP for their proxy’s glowing (but false) environmental impact report, indicates America has not had enough ecological disasters, and proves America is indeed oil independent. Republicans will never admit their excuses for building the Keystone pipeline are solely to benefit the oil industry, or that they have lied prodigiously to boost campaign donations from the oil industry, but of course they would not because it proves that big oil has controlled American energy policies for decades.
Regardless what the oil-whores in the Senate do, or say, or which bills they attempt to pass, Presidential approval means just that; President Obama is the sole voice in approving TransCanada’s permit to send tar across America’s agricultural heartland. The State Department said that “when EPA officially posts this draft, which will take about a week, we will begin a 45-day comment period, a public comment period,” and that gives the public ample time to express their opinion on the Keystone pipeline. Once Americans are armed with the facts and truth about allowing Canada to send its tar across America on its way to Europe and South America, maybe then the State Department, Democrats, and President Obama will take the time to finally speak the truth, and explain to the people that Republicans have lied, and that there is no benefit to this country in building what is nothing more than a dirty money-making scheme for the oil industry.
NOTE: The public is welcomed to submit their comments for the next 45 days HERE.
According to Republicans, America is a truly exceptional nation which is highly debatable, and it is pos ...
An alternative or extrinsic reason for doing something, especially when concealed or when differing fr ...
In the never-ending fight for government control, the oil industry continues wielding inordinate power a ...
The word responsible can mean being the cause or explanation of some occurrence or action, or answering ...
Politicians who lack factual data to make their point on an issue often use fallacies as a rhetorical to ...
Shiva(Moderator)
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 10:13 am
there is no excuse why Canada cannot send its oil from Alberta to Vancouver. It is one quarter of the distance or less than it is to Texas. Of course the oil companies will have to build their own refineries in Vancouver but they have a direct harbor to Europe. Canada is destroying its own environment and there are already plenty of leaks in the part of the Keystone pipeline that goes to the Midwest. this oil takes far more energy and water to process and while the Canadians have no problem with their country being destroyed, we do
There is no reason why that oil has to go across the United States to Texas when It could just go to Vancouver.
we said no
MC
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 10:38 am
I agree with your points. I’m curious as to why land was seized or condemned in Texas for the benefit of a private corporation. It doesn’t make sense. And you know something is wrong when this XL pipeline can unite people from the far left to the extreme right.
Sandra
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 8:03 pm
Vancouver, BC is against having the pipline going thru their Province. The citizens are pro environment and have demonstrated against the pipeline and there’s also the what’s in it for me by the Government. Besides damaging the environment, what are the cost and proft margins. These tar sands have created havoc on our environment across Canada but OM Harper is from Alberta though born in Ontario so he’s all for protecting his adopted Province and getting the pipeline built for the $$ despite the devastation processing the tar has caused to the Native populations and their waters ie high rates of Cancers even among the young, their food supply specifically fishing. There’s nothing safe about the tar sands or teh pipelines if they should rupture, the States in question will be devasted too.
Shiva(Moderator)
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 8:59 pm
Thats too bad. Its not coming here no matter how much Harper and Boehner profit
Royella
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 11:14 am
We did NOT elect big oil, or the Koch brothers into office, and big business needs to be removed from our political system, both in the payments they receive from our tax dollars in subsidies, as well as the money they bribe our politicians with. When did that become legal, anyway?
Victoria Lamb, MSHA
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 11:43 am
Does anyone know which 14 Senators are involved in this?
djchefron(Moderator)
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 12:05 pm
I tried to find out and the only thing that comes up is 7 of them are democrats.Now the ball is in Harry’s court.If it comes up for a vote then the fix is in.If the Senators are so proud then the 14 co-sponsors should stand and let the public know who has been bought
Sean
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 12:04 pm
“We did NOT elect big oil, or the Koch brothers into office, and big business needs to be removed from our political system, both in the payments they receive from our tax dollars in subsidies, as well as the money they bribe our politicians with. When did that become legal, anyway?”
It became legal January 21, 2010 in the Supreme Court decision on Citizens United.
It is apparently an extension of free speech to donate massive amounts of money to political campaigns. This pipeline is just another step towards a corporate America. I’m all for capitalism, but this is just another form of control. The GOP is owned and operated by large multinational corps that exert their influence over law makers to get what they want.
Cheryl
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 3:52 pm
Makes you wonder if they have ever read the Constitution. This is exactly what our forefathers tried to prevent with the 3 branchs.
Kim Moore
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 5:51 pm
NO!
“We The People” Should be the ones to make the decision. Not the corporations, not China, not anyone who will profit.
The people who live in the region & land owners who will be directly affected should be the ones to make this decision.
Just saying ;)
Jeffrey Clay Barcus
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 6:01 pm
In naming Senators onboard for the pipeline I’m sure you could start with Democratic Senator Mary Landrieu of Louisiana where most of the refineries are located. Then just take a look at the states where the pipeline will run and which Senators own property it will pass through or which own stock in companies that will benefit from the deal and then last but not least look and see which Senators are attached at the hip to the Koch Brothers for their campaign financing. Take a look at these items and you will find your Senate bills co-sponsers.
Reynardine
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 8:00 pm
I used your link and submitted my comment
JessG
Mar. 15th, 2013 at 11:32 pm
Well, if it rests on Senator Reid’s shoulders I am glad that I wrote him a letter while I was in DC for the Forward on Climate rally. This conglomerate of corporations doesn’t care about anything- not even the human race. There is nothing I have ever hated more. The Keystone XL and TransCanada represent almost all of the corporations I hate. It is monstrous.
Gary
Mar. 16th, 2013 at 12:53 am
@DJChefron (moderator), I have been reading and commenting sometimes here, so I appreciate this site. I am not going to look it up right now (as I have a lot of articles to catch up on), I always go to the site Thomas.com to see what senator or what rep votes on a certain bill. I don’t know that this one would be on the site, but, I will look when I get caught up.
Sammy
Mar. 16th, 2013 at 1:44 am
Thomas.com goes to the Rand Mcnally book site.
Perhaps you meant: thomas.loc.gov?
Craig
Mar. 16th, 2013 at 8:34 pm
I don’t understand what the fuss is about. Big Oil has already decided that they’re going to build the pipeline. They don’t need anyone’s permission. They’re the unelected government and they do as they will with impunity. However, this time, I have the feeling that “we the people” aren’t going to let them no matter what they or their puppets in Congress decide. Time will tell.
LisaLV711
Mar. 18th, 2013 at 5:01 am
Well, when those 14 Senators become president, they can make all the decisions they would like. Until then, they have no dog in this fight and should do like they have been doing since they have been Senators…find a quiet little room with a window and stare out of it.