During the healthcare reform debates, angry teabaggers and Republicans revolted against the idea that all Americans had a right to affordable healthcare, and despite passing both houses of Congress, President Obama’s signature, and the Supreme Court, presidential candidate Willard Romney pledges to repeal the Affordable Care Act (ACA) on his first day in office. The Republican argument is that the ACA is too expensive and a government takeover of healthcare even though several agencies determined that it will save taxpayers billions of dollars, provide the insurance industry with 30 million new policy holders, and give tens-of-millions of Americans access to affordable healthcare insurance.
On Sunday, Romney was asked if the government had a responsibility to provide health care to 50 million Americans who don’t have it, and he replied “we do provide care for people who don’t have insurance,” and proceeded to explain that emergency room visits are healthcare. In 2010, when he was asked if he believes in universal healthcare he said “it doesn’t make a lot of sense to have millions and millions of people who have no health insurance and yet who can go to the emergency room and get entirely free care, for which they have no responsibility.” Romney’s supports the principle argument for the individual mandate in the ACA and it’s no wonder because it is included in the universal healthcare law he signed while governor of Massachusetts. Romney explained how he determined it was prudent to require Massachusetts’ residents to carry healthcare insurance in his memoir.
Willard wrote that Massachusetts residents who didn’t have health insurance were receiving health care because federal law mandated hospitals to treat people who arrived at emergency rooms with acute conditions. His team realized the cost of treating people who didn’t have health insurance was already being paid for, and if they could use that money to help the uninsured buy insurance and obtain treatment before acute conditions developed, insuring everyone in the state might not be as expensive as paying for emergency room visits. Romney claimed it was an epiphany, but it is just good economics with the added benefit of a healthier population, and it is all down to regular checkups and preventative medicine as opposed to waiting until a condition is so advanced a visit to the ER was a last resort.
This incident appears to represent one of Romney’s failings, that despite sound economics, he panders to dispassionate conservatives and selfish teabaggers and reverts to unsound economics that are detrimental to 50 million uninsured Americans. What makes his “healthcare is an emergency room visit” statement all the more obscene is that the uninsured are guaranteed to suffer ill-health because he contends the ACA is too expensive and government takeover of healthcare.
Romney is fine with people waiting until they need to go to the emergency room to get care because they lack a primary care provider, and despite substantial proof that patients seeking to maintain optimal health are those who can afford healthcare insurance, Romney and Republicans still oppose giving every American the opportunity to purchase health insurance because they oppose the President, and over the weekend, vice-presidential candidate Paul Ryan propagated a myth that President Obama’s health law includes death panels.
At a University of Central Florida town hall in Orlando, after hearing Ryan repeatedly call for the repeal of the Affordable Care Act, a senior citizen asked “will you address the death panels that we’re going to have?” Instead of discouraging the man’s reference to “death panels,” Ryan laughed and said, “The death panels, well! That’s not the word I’d choose, it’s actually called what I refer to as this board of 15 bureaucrats–the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB). It sounds fairly innocuous.” It is innocuous because the IPAB’s job is making recommendations to Congress for lowering health care spending if Medicare costs exceed a target growth rate by modifying payments to providers, but it does not “include any recommendation to ration health care, or restrict benefits or modify eligibility criteria.” However, truth is not Ryan’s purview and with Romney, has done everything to cast aspersion on the President’s signature healthcare law and their reason for opposing it is funding tax cuts for the wealthy.
Romney and Ryan are campaigning on shrinking the government to fund monumental tax cuts for corporations and the wealthy, and although they are remiss to give specifics to fund trillions in tax cuts, they have promised to slash spending on programs that provide healthcare for the poor, children, and seniors. Medicaid and Medicare have been singled out for Romney and Ryan’s cuts, and the people who will suffer most are the uninsured whose only option for medical treatment is a visit to the emergency room when their health is in jeopardy. If Romney is victorious in November, then the uninsured person left with no option but going to the emergency room for treatment will find there are no funds to pay for treatment. There will be dreaded death panels, but they will be from steep cuts to Medicaid and Medicare Romney and Ryan require to pay for the wealthy’s tax cuts.
Romney’s assertion that Americans already have universal healthcare because they can visit an emergency room for an acute medical condition is not a flip-flop, it is part of his plan for America’s uninsured. He is not confused about the economic benefits of the ACA, because he has no intention of supporting any program to provide affordable healthcare to millions of uninsured Americans. Romney has made it perfectly clear that he does not care, or worry, about nearly half of America and that includes their health. What he does care about is eliminating his tax liability and if slashing Medicare, Medicaid, and repealing the Affordable Care Act will fund the wealthy’s tax cuts, then 30-50 million uninsured Americans can expect nothing from Romney except “don’t get sick” because even a visit to the emergency room will not be an option.

Nefer
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 10:22 am
Romney also needs to be called to account for saying that the care is free. It is not free at all. ERs have to treat you, but they don’t have to do it for free (and they don’t). The uninsured person will get a bill for possibly thousands of dollars with no means to pay it off.
Yes, when that person can’t pay, the cost is passed on to the rest of us, but that person is not off the hook. They may now be staring at bankruptcy.
loading...
clarence swinney
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 10:50 am
REGRESSION NOT PROGRESSION
INCOME GROWTH (MEDIAN)OF MIDDLE CLASS
START—END——INCREASE–% CHANGE rounded
1950-1980—$18,000—$31,000—-$13,000———75%
1980-2008—$31,000—$31,000—-$000000———000000
Top 1% grew 281% –1979-2007
SHARE OF WEALTH
BOTTOM— 99%—–TOP 1%
1922————63%——37%
1976————80%——20%
2004————66%——34%
loading...
A Walkaway
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 12:06 pm
Most people don’t understand how bad it was for the poor in the early years of the 20th century… and that it was not exactly a picnic for the middle class as well. More people lived on farms or had gardens in those years (less those who were stuck in urban areas and there were even gardens and farms in some cities) and it wasn’t quite as bad as now… where most people don’t have a clue how to raise their own food.
America was doing its best during the years that the rich had the least share of the wealth.
loading...
A Walkaway
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 11:18 am
The worthless bastard of a liar doesn’t even think about chronic medical conditions, which aren’t dealt with in the emergency room (until they become so bad that life itself is threatened). They don’t understand the situations that people find themselves in.
It ties back to their idea of “Christianity” (and this holds true for the Mormons too… they can claim to be “Christian” even as their claims are disproved by their un-Christ-like behavior). Personal responsibility – you’re responsible for everything that happens to you. Get sick? What did you do to bring that on you? Have an accident? Well, maybe you should have taken the bus or decided not to go to work that day! That’s the sort of things they say to people! (Yes, I’ve heard it all!)
Their idea is that everything that happens to you is because of your personal failings and “SIN!!!”. They also believe that your responsibility is to go to “God” so that it’s magically healed or dealt with. If God doesn’t “HEAL!” you, then you’re holding onto some sort of secret sin. (A lot of walkaways are people with chonic illnesses, who got sick of years of that sort of treatment!)
Oh, and I have to second what Nefer said… with this bit of information. In most cases the hospital writes off your debt but still tries to collect it, and they will hound people for years. The collection agencies they have contracts with also have a provision that a certain percentage of their accounts will always be turned over to them for collection, so even if you ARE paying, you may find yourself the target of harassment and threats from a collection agency, which gets the money for profit.
They’ll even fight you in bankruptcy court, and you may even find yourself getting dunning calls after you enter bankruptcy – even after your case was finished!
loading...
ibwilliamwsi
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 11:39 am
“Treat and street” is what they call it. Stop the bleeding, get the heart beating again, get him/her breathing again and dump them on the street with a bill for tens of thousands of dollars that will never be paid and they write it off as an uncollected debt thereby owing less in taxes. It’s a scam all the way around, and Bishop Rommey is not going to let his good friends in the healthcare industry lose a bad debt write-off.
loading...
Lynda Harrison
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 1:35 pm
What a sorry excuse for a human being. Hopefully, 99% of us will vote overwhelmingly to reject him as the next President.
loading...
D. W. Skinner
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 1:44 pm
I’m in Missouri… I had a conversation with an 80 year old lifelong Republican who said this to me: “I will no longer proclaim to be a Republican. First of all I’m a woman and their views do not represent mine. Many of my friends are gay and the republicans viewpoints do not represent mine. I was a member of a union who represented me beautifully in my vocation for many years. The Republicans views do not represent mine. My father was Jewish and my mother Native American. The Republican’s views do not represent mine. I don’t believe in the conspiracy theories of our President being a Kenyan, or a socialist or a communist or any of the things they want to paint him as being so they can cover up their hatred that he’s a black man. I am sick to death that the party I thought made me Lincoln-proud is now just Sarah Palin-stupid. And proud of it. On my next registration, I am an Independent. And when I pull the lever this November it will be Democratic because I would rather be a moderate Democrat than a extremist Republican!”
loading...
A Walkaway
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 2:09 pm
I hope that there are a lot more Republicans like her!
loading...
Colleen
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 4:19 pm
I was a Republican like her. Sick of what the party has become. This year I changed my affiliation to Independent. I too will vote Democrat. Abraham Lincoln must be rolling over in his grave. To think that the Republican party has become a bunch of lying hypocrites who are trying to tell everyone else how to live is a disgrace.
loading...
Shiva (Moderator)
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 5:46 pm
About the only people left for Mitt to Stiff is…….yes…the Mormon church
loading...
A Walkaway
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 6:28 pm
I know that Diebold is owned by admitted right-wingers, but the question that came to my mind is if they were Mormons too.
loading...
Enjay in E MT
Sep. 25th, 2012 at 7:56 pm
It would be so much easier if Mitt just gave us a list of the people/corporations he would represent if he did become president.
loading...
Paul Federman
Sep. 26th, 2012 at 4:42 am
Mitt Romney he enacted healthcare while he was governor of Massachusetts. Today 98% of the states citizens have insurance. And everybody likes it. Now he says it was good enough for Massachusetts citizens, but not good enough for the rest of the country. But in a July 2009 op-ed in ‘USA Today’, Romney thought the President could learn a thing or two from the plan he signed into law in Massachusetts, including using the individual mandate as an incentive for people to buy insurance. Mitt Romney’s Advice For ObamaCare: Look At RomneyCare. Mitt Romney once touted his plan to Obama as a model for health care reform. He didn’t mention keeping it at the state level. “Our experience also demonstrates that getting every citizen insured doesn’t have to break the bank. First, we established incentives for those who were uninsured to buy insurance. Using tax penalties, as we did… encourages “free riders” to take responsibility for themselves rather than pass their medical costs on to others.” Just another episode in the continuing flip flop saga of Mitt Romney. Remember, Romney doesn’t need health coverage. He can just purchase the hospital. Just another example of the hypocracy of the Republican Party.
“Romney now is turning himself into a pretzel because he can’t admit that that’s what he did in Massachusetts and that’s what he used to think was a perfectly good idea,” The New Republic’s Jonathan Cohn said.
Emergency room care is the most expensive way to cover the uninsured, not only because the taxpayer (read: you) pays for it with higher premiums, but because folks without insurance are more likely to wait until their ailments need serious, protracted treatment. Catching a disease in its earliest stages can save a life, but it can also save money. Lots of money.
Late News. MIAMI (AP) Sept 20.— Speaking at a Univision forum Wednesday night Mitt Romney says it’s a compliment to be called the grandfather of Obamacare, the health care law championed by…
loading...