8 Responses to John McCain Praises Obama’s Firing of Gen. McChrystal

1. Sarah Jones

   Jun. 27th, 2010 at 6:59 pm

   I wish more of the Right would support the President during these tough times. They don’t have to agree with him, but they can have policy disagreements based on facts and ideology that don’t need to come from the place of utter contempt and pettiness for a lost election.

   I’m very glad John McCain isn’t our President, but I’m also really glad he did the honorable thing here. As a military man, he knows that McChrystal was out of line. I’m also glad he reminded people, as the President did, that McChrystal has a long record of good service to our country. There’s no reason to vilify him, just as there’s no reason to vilify the President when the Right doesn’t agree with him.

   What do you think? 0  0
   • F Joy

     Jun. 28th, 2010 at 12:45 pm

     I agree. At least McCain has some integrity somewhere. I was beginning to wonder. Obama had to do what he did. McChrystal must have been looking for some degree of a public profile to have granted such a request to Rolling Stone in the first place. Somehow his demands for extra troops were leaked last year. Even though Obama deliberated for some time before making a decision on sending extra troops, maybe McChrystal thinks that’s how to get things done through public humiliation. I think this incident was embarrassing for the President and the country. Remarks were made about our French allies and it is my understanding that those remarks are what infuriated the President immediately. I give General McChrystal credit at being a good soldier for this country, but I would seriously have to question his leadership ability in high command because he doesn’t have a broad enough perspective and he needs too much attention. A great General sets an example with the line of command and puts his country first.

     What do you think? 0  0
2. Shiva (Moderator)

   Jun. 27th, 2010 at 7:16 pm

   I have always thought the highest of McCain, but the constant pandering to the church of whats happening now is taking away from what is otherwise a brilliant career. Saying on one side we are all gods children about immigrants, then saying they must be sent home and a thousand other examples detracts what good thing man has done. You are only as good as your last interview or statement in Washington. Today he is a good guy

   On the other hand, there is no future for General McChrystal. He is done. Fried and laid out on paper towels. There is no place he can go now and have credibility in a military job. Another thing is I think the story is this was a bar rom discourse. it wasn’t. The rolling stone had access to the general for a month

   “Let’s stipulate that allowing a reporter from Rolling Stone with a skeptic’s view of the war in Afghanistan unfettered access for a month was not the best career move. But those who’ve read the full piece by Michael Hastings — as opposed to just the juicy bits being tossed around cable news — might be forgiven for wondering what exactly got him whacked so quickly. Or at least, you might wonder if it has less to do with what the general said and more to do with the relentless velocity and recklessness of the modern media ecosystem.”

   What do you think? 0  0
   • John

     Jun. 28th, 2010 at 7:08 am

     “On the other hand, there is no future for General McChrystal.”

     His penance for voting for Obama.

     What do you think? 0  0
3. Anne

   Jun. 27th, 2010 at 7:24 pm

   As a military veteran, John McCain is keenly aware of military protocol. This is a welcome exception to his recent record of pandering the the far right, and is a bright spot against the bleak reality of his willingness to debase himself in order to win.

   What do you think? 0  0
   • Shiva (Moderator)

     Jun. 27th, 2010 at 7:45 pm

     Anne I think you would make an excellent blogger for this site. Go for it

     What do you think? 0  0
4. Giggle T

   Jun. 27th, 2010 at 8:16 pm

   As far as I know, the military has a rule that you cannot publically disgree with the President’s policies, as he is the Commander-in-Chief. Obama took the right action here by relieving McChrystal. It’s unfortunate that McChrystal said what he said, given his record of service. But he should have known better than to open up his mouth. If he doesn’t agree with Obama and thinks he’s an idiot, McChrystal should have resigned first.

   What do you think? 0  0
5. Viva

   Jun. 28th, 2010 at 6:16 am

   McCain had no other option unless he wanted to paint himself in a way that he would personally find unbearable. Lip service to the Far Right is fine with him when it’s simply a matter of “conscience” – because he has no dog in that fight.

   What do you think? 0  0