Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
Michigan Demands Democracy by Rejecting Emergency Manager Legislation
more from Black Liberal Boomer
It was a great day for the nation when President Barack Obama was re-elected to a second term in office, and it was also a good day in Michigan when voters cast their ballots to reject Proposal 1 (which asked voters to support the continuation of Public Act 4, also known as the Emergency Manager Law), Gov. Rick Snyder’s naked attempt to hijack democracy from the grasp of financially struggling communities on the premise that we should all trust him to do what is best for us – even at the expense of forfeiting our right to vote.
For those outside of Michigan who have not been following this issue via MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow’s excellent reporting (her colleague Ed Schultz has been doing a good job as well), the purpose of PA 4 was to beef up an existing piece of legislation known as PA 72 (implemented in 1990) that provided for the appointment of emergency financial managers to oversee and have total control over the finances of local governing bodies. This was not enough for Gov. Snyder, who devised Public Act 4 and passed it into law in 2011 with the help of his colleagues in the Republican-dominated Michigan legislature giving him Almighty powers to appoint emergency managers who could – and did - seize operational control of entire communities at a whim if he felt they were not capable of getting their act together fast enough. Under PA 4, these emergency managers had the right to void all union contracts and completely ignore any and all locally elected officials as they force-fed their own remedies down the throats of these struggling communities with no required input from the communities themselves. Interestingly enough, all of these communities are largely – if not predominantly – African American.
Which is why so many of us who were determined to defeat Proposal 1 constantly reminded anyone who would listen that this was a blatant assault on democracy. You cannot simply empower a governor – or anyone else – with the ability to steal the vote of an entire community under the guise that this is somehow ‘helping’ that community. Stealing someone’s vote is never helping them to become a more responsible citizen just like stealing someone’s car is not helping them to become a safer driver.
Keep in mind that no one would argue about the struggling condition of Detroit Public Schools, or the cities of Benton Harbor or Pontiac or any of the other governing bodies that were shackled with this wrong-headed legislation. We live here. We know how bad it is. But no one has ever offered any proof that Gov. Snyder is somehow more trustworthy and has our interests at heart more so than the local officials that we elected. And if any of them prove unfit for the job it should be up to us to get rid of them via the ballot box, not via power grab. Why doesn’t Detroit deserve democracy? Or Benton Harbor? Or Pontiac? Who is Gov. Snyder to say that our right as Americans to cast our vote and to have that vote respected must first be approved by him? Who and and where does he think he is?
The voters of Michigan know what time it is, and that’s why we voted to defeat Proposal 1 by a margin of 52-48 percent. And I’m proud to say that at a Nov. 7 Detroit School Board special meeting (presided over by actual elected officials who were actually elected by the people of Detroit to represent their interests) it was reported that the voters of Detroit were the ones most responsible for the defeat of Proposal 1, delivering a city-wide result that was more than 80 percent opposed to Prop 1. It is also worth noting that polls were kept open late in Detroit because lines remained out the door all around the city close to the 8 pm original closing time. My son got home at 9 and reported seeing folks still in line.
And they say Detroiters don’t care enough to vote? Please believe me when I say that Detroiters have no problem voting when they see their interests being threatened – as with Proposal 1 – or when they see their interests being championed – as with the re-election of President Barack Obama.
Make no mistake, this does not mean the fight is over because the opposition is already devising back door efforts to steal our victory. Soon-to-be-exiting Emergency Financial Manager Roy Roberts said in the Detroit Free Press today that he planned to hang around awhile and would consider whether or not to leave. Yes, this is the kind of I-Am-King-You-Are-Peasants mentality that we are dealing with here. And this from a man who just last week said in a letter to the governor that he might have to resign and take his marbles and go home if Prop 1 is defeated.
I say it’s time he took his own advice and started packing those marbles. Before we have to pack them on his behalf.
On Monday, Jan. 2, to start the New Year off right and hit the ground running, a loudly vocal Detroit cr ...
The reason Michigan matters, the reason why we can't afford to stop paying attention to what's going on ...
So now comes the report from the appointed state 'team' in Michigan led by State Treasurer Andy Dillon s ...
The Great Lakes State of Michigan has long been a "swing state" of sorts for many years; we regularly sw ...
Republicans in Michigan are busy little bees attacking the rights of voters in general and labor specifi ...
JAmith
Nov. 8th, 2012 at 11:13 am
Yes, we did defeat Oligarchy and the New Right’s EFM; but, he fully intends on restoring a previous law much the same. We are tired of them claiming to be Republicans. They are NOT. We want our party back. If they are so sure that the base wants their Theocracy/Oligarchy and hundreds of ALEC corporate-made laws…then stop being chicken..s..ts and call yourselves who you really are…The New Right of Paul Weyrich. We, republicans, can make our choice – to join your party or reclaim our own! I cannot believe that Michigan voted in Obama and yet continued to keep the New Right congress/house. This will be investigated as the state has ALL ESS-100 machines which are highly suspicious. The battle is not over for Democracy here in Michigan and we have just begun!!
NativeSonKY
Nov. 8th, 2012 at 11:22 am
Good to hear! Anytime you can kick the privatization of our Democracy to the curb it is to be commended!
Shiva (Moderator)
Nov. 8th, 2012 at 11:31 am
it is totally beyond me how anything like this could ever get passed. Except for the fact that it was Republicans that did it. Those idiot should’ve known that if it was presented to the people they would vote it down.
The fact that these emergency managers were also giving or selling community owned property to corporations for their own use had to have had something to do with it. If this would’ve one across Michigan they would’ve torn up entire communities.
Entities that need help should be given help. If these emergency managers are so smart why can’t they just go out and get help without having to have power to do away with duly elected people?
I’m not sure what definition this fits under. Is it fascism? Is it socialism where the government totally tries to take over? Is the governor of Michigan secretly a Nazi? Or is he just simply owned by the Koch brothers
Reynardine
Nov. 8th, 2012 at 11:39 am
It’s called autocracy, Shiva, like the Tsar had. You see what happened to the Tsar. Meanwhile, if Mr. Roberts won’t pick up his marbles and go home, I’d suggest it’s because he lost them.
Mike From Michigan
Nov. 8th, 2012 at 12:46 pm
Michiganders voted No on all 6. I live in a city wih an EM and now we are in deep trouble because without an EM we are now being ran by local dictators i preferred the one tied to the Governor. Without the EFM we would have less police, more crime, and more of a mess. Have any of you ever been to a city with an EM, There is no way you can defend leaders like those in Detroit, Flint, Pontiac etc.Bankruptcy here we come and people in the end will say dang i wish we kept the EM
Shiva (Moderator)
Nov. 8th, 2012 at 1:02 pm
an emergency manager does not have to take authority away from the people. He can certainly be there to advise with a certain amount of authority. But you cannot take the right of the people to vote in the people that they want to run their schools and cities. There is no reason an emergency manager cannot be effective without taking over complete power.
( I lived in Lapeer all my life except for the last 10 years, I know Michigan has problems)
Freeman Cooper
Nov. 9th, 2012 at 4:31 am
Wow, it would seem that “Mike from Michigan” seem to be the only right-wing, conservative, GOP Teabagger that commented on this article. Mike, it’s better to have a city run by ELECTED officials, rather than by self-appointed DICTATORS. If you don’t like the people of Michigan rejecting a dictator, then nothing’s keeping you from moving your retarded @$$ to some other state. In fact, you’d be doing Michigan a BIG favor.
Sally
Nov. 8th, 2012 at 2:31 pm
Mike, I am in Midland and yes, we voted everything down. 2-6 were attempts to put things in the Constitution that do not belong there. The ER bill may be working where you are, but talk to Benton Harbor, where they took away the town water access to build a private golf resort. No input from citizens. That is not democracy, and neither was that hastily passed law. And I think Snyder is a crook.
Chris
Nov. 9th, 2012 at 8:09 am
It might be autocratic to the community that losses their power, but what about me whose taxpayer money is being mispent by another community with no input from me. There is no democracy when I have no control over what MY tax paid dollars are being spent and wasted on. If citizens of these failing communities got off their collective ass and fixed their own problems sooner, then maybe legislation like this would never have to see the light of day.
Shiva (Moderator)
Nov. 9th, 2012 at 9:00 am
1) You have never had control of where your taxes are spent.
2) You seem to think the problems in an area is a very narrow little thing. Its not. Are you assuming that communities can control jobs and hiring? Yes they can, its called complete capitulation to corporate control. Then you are right back to Emergency managers taking the right to vote away from people.