Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
64% of Americans Agree With Obama: Don’t Release The Bin Laden Photos
By: Guest ContributorMay. 8th, 2011more from Guest Contributor
A new NBC News poll found that the vast majority of Americans agree with President Obama’s decision not to release the death photos of Osama Bin Laden. 64% of those polled thought that the photos should not be released.
The NBC News poll will be released in full on Monday night, but a sneak peek was released today. A majority of those polled strongly believe that the Obama administration should not release the photos. Another 12% agreed but not as strongly. 24% strongly believed that Obama should release the photos, and of this group 5% strongly believed that the photos should be released.
Despite the complaints of many on the right who want to paint not releasing the photos as some sort of Obama failure, most Americans are fine with not seeing the photos. It isn’t like the government is hiding anything from us. We know Bin Laden is dead. There seems to be very little to be gained by releasing these photos, except for the fact that the media stands to gain an image to plaster everywhere and another news cycle out of Bin Laden’s death.
I agreed with Jon Stewart’s point earlier in the week that we need more honest coverage of the wars that America is currently involved in. We need to see pictures of everything, but I believe that the Bin Laden photos are not the most relevant starting point. We need to see video of the consequences of these war decisions on our brave men and women on the front lines. Instead of painting every returning solider who is missing a limb as a brave warrior, let’s tell it how it really is.
Show us how these people are being permanently disabled by war. Highlight not the occasional uplifting outcome, but wounded warriors who return home and struggle with the day to day challenges of their new and forever changed lives. Let’s talk about the mental illness and PTSD that is torturing those who fought for their country in Iraq and Afghanistan. Let’s show the American people what our bullets and bombs are doing in those countries. It’s time for concrete images must be added to the vague jargon of “fighting for freedom.”
Releasing the Bin Laden photos would do none of these things. The Bin Laden death photos would serve as a justification of the wars over the last decade. They would do nothing to show the real face of war. The reason why so many Republicans want the photos released is because they will use those photos of dead Bin Laden to claim that they were right all along. War is the answer.
al-Qaeda has confirmed the death of Bin Laden. With the exception of a few conspiracy theorists, the vast majority of people believe that he is dead.
The neo-cons want the photos released so that they can use them to argue for more war, but Osama Bin Laden’s gaping head wound is not an accurate portrait of war. It was the outcome of a CIA operation.
America needs to see what war really looks like, and a flag waving yeah, we got him look at Bin Laden with his head blown off moment would be manipulated until it became more preemptive war propaganda. Releasing the Bin Laden photos would fit into the way America’s politicians and media have always portrayed these wars. It would be another feel good moment used to sanitize and whitewash the realities of war.
Those calls for Bin Laden’s photos on the right are really a masked siren song for more preemptive war. Don’t let their flag waving full you. The neo-cons will use anything as justification for the blood on their hands.
After President Obama stated in an upcoming 60 Minutes interview that he has decided not release the dea ...
On his radio show today Glenn Beck claimed that something isn't right with the story of the death of Osa ...
On The Daily Show, Jon Stewart not only argued for the release of the Bin Laden photos, but he also ha ...
Republicans are scrambling to give themselves and George W. Bush credit for the death of Osama Bin Laden ...
Collective closure of our national 9/11 wound has finally come to America, as President Obama announced ...
Reynardine
May. 8th, 2011 at 1:19 pm
I am glad to see that two thirds of the country have recovered from the days when they were howling for the blood of the Dixie Chicks and pouring French wine down the storm drains. May they remain sober, and may the other third never gain the upper hand.
Jtl
May. 8th, 2011 at 4:14 pm
How many times did cheney and his spawn vote for release to make sure he stays out of jail!
Glad that the majority agree not to publish…we have enough salacious republican meme out there!
Marvin
May. 8th, 2011 at 2:30 pm
I agree with not releasing the photos. But my main issue is with this even being an “issue” in the first place. Why do people always focus on trivial stuff?
nk007
May. 8th, 2011 at 5:02 pm
Well said Marvin!
mick
May. 9th, 2011 at 4:22 pm
Now “truth” is “trivial” ?
WTH
May. 10th, 2011 at 3:03 am
The Truth Defined: There are multiple arrays of definitions of the “Truth”: Truth by definition is the way things really are, the true or actual state of a matter. It is conformity with fact or reality. Truth is also consistent; not contradictory. No reality is contingent upon our view of it. The bottom line is that Truth cannot be relative, if it is then it is not truth! If truth actually is relative, then so is the statement that truth is relative, and therefore it need not be believed by anyone.
BonnyBrown
May. 8th, 2011 at 3:16 pm
I’m sure you guys were all fine with Bush hiding things from the public under the claim of “it’s for the greater good.” Right, right?
majii
May. 8th, 2011 at 3:25 pm
Did you forget that it was under GWB that the PATRIOT Act was passed that, for the first time in U.S. history, legalized the things he hid from the public. Making a point is one thing, but any point one is attempting to make should be buttressed by FACTS.
As far as GWB “hiding” things, I can imagine you’re one of those who blamed Obama for the huge deficit, a large part of which was hidden by GWB and the republicans in supplemental budgets for 2 wars. President Obama gets the blame because he revealed the out of control spending that went on for 8 long years while “conservatives” didn’t open their mouths to protest one bit.
You can’t run with the big dogs, if you’re still a wee pup!!
Sally
May. 8th, 2011 at 3:19 pm
I guess the other third also thinks water boarding is some nifty parlor game that elicits valuable information, just like Dickie and his shifty daughter said again today. I am disgusted that these are the same people who claim to be better Christians than anyone else…they advocate torture, murder, and everything Jesus was against, and then wonder why peaceful Muslims don’t trust them? Can we just never vote GOP again, please?
majii
May. 8th, 2011 at 3:29 pm
I find it ironic, Sally, that the “Party of God” and “followers of Christ” embrace torture when Jesus was tortured! IMO, these people have strayed so far from the teachings of Christ, that they should be ashamed of invoking his name, but they’re not. They’ll do anything to persuade the American public that they’re the right people to run the country. As a Christian, something that grieves me to no end is the way that they’re leading millions to perdition.
Jtl
May. 8th, 2011 at 4:16 pm
They would shut up if we could only use them in the demonstration tapes! note that hanratty has not kept his word to be WB’ed! Cluck Cluck Cluck
KFitzer
May. 8th, 2011 at 3:38 pm
Those on the right clamoring for the release of the photos do so only because it is contrary to what President Obama decided. Had he released the photos, those same voices would be condemning him for inciting terrorism. And you KNOW this, man!!!
Darnell
May. 8th, 2011 at 11:00 pm
If you’ve seen the movie, “THE TILLMAN STORY,” then you should want to see a picture of Bid Laden – whether you’re liberal or conservative.
Pat Tillman was a football player who quit the NFL to fight in Afghanistan for his country. He was killed by friendly fire, but the government lied about it (even to his family), in order to position this high-profile soldier as hero in order to promote the war effort.
Don’t believe everything the government tells you.
Lokis
May. 9th, 2011 at 1:43 pm
cannot we huddle in prayer and thank our warrior presidents and their minions in the war against terror and freedom. Now is the time to increase our collective diligence and put some real support behind the military – if we do not consider doubling up on the budget of the armed forces we are doomed to failure. Let us strive to make this war even half as successful as the war on drugs!
GoodAmerican
May. 9th, 2011 at 4:17 pm
lol, if yer NOT thinking like an American, if yer NOT thinking that “our” gov’ts mode of operation is simply to lie, lie and then lie some more in order to get their way with US..then yer not REALLY paying attention to WHAT theyre saying…yer just watching TV, lol.
Peace, truth, justice, and prosperity, in-spite of the Bast@rds.
Thebes
May. 9th, 2011 at 4:25 pm
Thank you for supporting the Ministry of Truth.
crazy canuck
May. 9th, 2011 at 9:02 pm
I do find it hard to believe with the number of cellphone cameras out there in the military, that not one soldier involved in Osama’s dead body’s journey, didn’t pull out his cellphone and snap a trophy pic.
Right now that pic would be worth millions
Kinda weird that’s all. Release the pics don’t release the pics, doesn’t change a thing. Americans are slowly losing their freedoms due to the fear mongering that the govt. and media is purporting.
Shiva (Moderator)
May. 9th, 2011 at 9:23 pm
Not sure they are allowed to carry phones on covert missions such as this one. But you are right. Then again when others got a hold of it, it would be photoshopped and all kinds of mean and nasty stuff done with it
Ignia
May. 10th, 2011 at 2:04 am
My favorite war shot:
axisoflogic.com/artman/up...
Story:
theimmoralminority.blogsp...
I think these atrocities should be posted in a great deal of places. Not to mention what it costs our troops… and the civilians over there. What our real impact is in their territory.
While I can never be angry at soldiers in general, and even have some (very tiny) sympathy for the conditions and trauma that may have caused these young men to snap and become cold blooded killers… America needs to know about this. While always keeping the lessons of Vietnam in our minds; the troops are not to blame except in the direst of circumstances. The politicians are. The ones who give the orders are. The ones who turn a blind eye are. And most especially:
The ones who pull a shroud over everything and try to hide it.