Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Prosser Allegedly Chokes Female Justice
By: Sarah JonesJun. 25th, 2011more from Sarah Jones
Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Prosser, the man who called the Chief Justice a “bitch” while threatening to destroy her and went on to be re-elected after a dubious election of “found votes”, has allegedly choked his colleague Justice Ann Walsh Bradley during discussions surrounding the union-busting bill last week.
Justice Prosser, who ran his re-election campaign as “complement” to Walker, was also a former Republican legislator and Assembly Speaker. Last week, before announcing their 4-3 decision that overturned county Judge Sumi’s void on the collective bargaining law that was passed in clear and documented violation of Open Meeting Laws, Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson let her written dissent speak to the partisan nature of the hasty court ruling, which took place just eight days after hearing oral arguments.
Abrahamson is, of course, the “bitch” Prosser said he would “destroy”. Prosser justified his actions by accusing the two female justices, Abrahamson and Bradley, of being “manipulative.” During debate centering on the overturning of Judge Sumi’s void last week, Bradley asked Prosser to leave her office. He responded by putting his hands around her neck.
If being manipulative is justification for choking, one has to wonder why no one has yet assaulted Justice Prosser or his “complements”. Maybe because in a civilized society, we don’t put our hands around the necks of ideological opponents.
The Wisconsin State Journal reports:
Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice David Prosser allegedly grabbed fellow Justice Ann Walsh Bradley around the neck in an argument in her chambers last week, according to at least three knowledgeable sources.
Details of the incident, investigated jointly by Wisconsin Public Radio and the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism, remain sketchy. The sources spoke on the condition that they not be named, citing a need to preserve professional relationships.
They say an argument that occurred before the court’s release of a decision upholding a bill to curtail the collective bargaining rights of public employees culminated in a physical altercation in the presence of other justices. Bradley purportedly asked Prosser to leave her office, whereupon Prosser grabbed Bradley by the neck with both hands.
Justice Prosser, contacted Friday afternoon by the Center, declined comment: “I have nothing to say about it.” He repeated this statement after the particulars of the story — including the allegation that there was physical contact between him and Bradley — were described. He did not confirm or deny any part of the reconstructed account.
This incident was reportedly turned over to the Wisconsin Judicial Commission, which cannot confirm or deny if they are investigating it.
This is not only horrifying in its physical abuse, but also because it was predictable. Prosser has been known to be a man bearing no respect for women and a man who freely embraces his erratic temperament. He has previously displayed a lack of interest in controlling himself while performing the duties of his job. There is no excuse for putting one’s hands around a colleague’s neck. There is no excuse for physically touching anyone during an argument, and this is, of course, against the law. We expect our justices to act in accordance with the law, even if their temperament is that of a spoiled, angry child who uses threats to intimidate people with whom he disagrees.
This is the man conservatives were crowing about getting re-elected, even after reports surfaced of his inability to control his temper around women. This is the man whose re-election only occurred after the GAB declined to investigate the logs of ballot bag abnormalities, failure to maintain secure chain of custody, open ballot bags and tags that didn’t match logs after 7,000 votes were found a day and half after the election results initially went for his challenger, JoAnne Kloppenburg.
Once again, we have to ask conservatives if what they are doing is so right, why do they have to keep breaking laws to do it? And we need to ask ourselves, is this what democracy looks like?
After news leaked that Republican Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice David Prosser had allegedly choked Sup ...
Justice moves slowly but surely forward in Wisconsin as the DA refers the Prosser choking incident to a ...
A giant, angry, inflatable balloon man representing conservative Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice David P ...
When you think about the justices on your state supreme court, you probably picture them as grown ups wh ...
In case you were wondering where justice was hiding in Wisconsin, she’s reared her head in Waukesha Coun ...
Harold P. Donle
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 3:06 pm
Why is this assclown not under arrest. Anyone else had done this they would be cooling their heels in a jail cell. And I am sick and tired of hearing these people referred to as conservatives, they are not conservatives, at best they are thugs, at worst they are fucking Nazis. Stop disgracing conservatives by applying that honorable term to these punks.
Sarah Jones
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 3:29 pm
I wondered the same thing. Interesting how the entire country was in an outrage over a picture of a penis, but we will tolerate not only illegal but clearly female abusing behavior like this. Just wait – this will be justified as he justified his last behavior.
As for the label of conservatives, while I agree that these folks are not acting like conservatives, they have hijacked that movement and it is the label they give themselves and the label under which they pass their egregious laws aimed at hurting the majority of Americans. There is nothing truly conservative about it, but it is up to the conservative wing to start calling these folks out. This man was just supposedly re-elected by conservatives, and they gave great voice to their support of him and their failure to support a county judge doing exactly what a county judge is authorized to do as checks and balances on our legislators. This is just one more way the modern day conservative party is gaining the label of unlawful behavior. They want activist courts, which they got with Prosser. Ideology trumps law for the extremists of both parties.
Aaron
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 4:03 pm
Bradley and Abrahamson are guilty of playing politics like Sumi did. This will go nowhere because there isn’t anything to the story. Placing your hand on someones shoulders is not wrapping your hand around a neck, it is not “choking”, there was no shaking or restriction of movement of Bradley. With the logic of the story it would be to comparable to say someone was trying to eat a person’s face when they are kissing. Oh look he is biting her!!!
The timeline is somewhat strange too isn’t it. An act of violence, choking in a judges chambers, hum….. lets wait over a week to talk about it??? Not before the decision was released? Not in an official letter? No charges? Maybe, she needs a legal opinion of what to label the “abuse” as! Grasping at air, not straws here.
I do have to say it is sad you continue to report the 7000 vote issue as “found votes” the truth is the numbers reported 20 some hours later matched EXACTLY to the numbers reported that night out of Brookfield. It was a PRINTING ISSUE where the AP did not get all the columns from reporting cities and gave an UNOFFICIAL total not including Brookfield. Very simple.
I realize you need to feed the drones some koolaid but the level of dishonesty in your reporting is going to compromise your integrity.
PS. A big reason for the outrage of PENIS pictures is that UNDERAGE children were involved! Weiner outed himself during his pres-conference stating “to the best of my knowledge everyone was of legal age”
Sarah Jones
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 4:09 pm
Why don’t you link to this proof you have that he put them around her shoulders (which is still assault)? The conservative WSJ said neck. At any rate, the fact that you are justifying this behavior is exactly why Americans are getting turned off by modern day conservatives.
There is no justification for it. If playing politics (a charge you have not proven, and even the Wall Street Journal acknowledged Sumi’s authority to do what she did) is a justification for assault in your mind, then you are truly sick.
As for the ballots and the election, I’m confident that I know more about it than you do, and had you followed the links provided, you might be aware of that fact. I wonder why you are supporting someone who was already indicted and had to plead her way out of fraud charges, then during this election, did not allow a proper canvas of the ballots and only told the canvassers about the “Found” votes minutes before a press conference two days later, after calling for canvassing a day earlier with no explanation. No chance was given to go through the actual ballots and no, the numbers didn’t match up. The GAB certified that election without ever reviewing the challenges based on ripped, wide open ballot bags whose chain of secure custody was broken.
Your desperation to discredit the ugliness of Justice Prosser’s alleged illegal actions leaves you no choice but to try to personally discredit me, since you can’t discredit the facts.
It is against the law to assault someone. Spin that.
You have just spent your time defending a man of assaulting a woman and crowing that it will go nowhere. Your ethics and the principles for which you claim to stand are in jeopardy.
Perhaps you would have preferred I use the verb “strangle”, and we call Justice Prosser the alleged Wisconsin Strangler.
Cathy
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 10:20 pm
Excellent article–and reply!
Sarah Jones
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 12:04 am
Thanks Cathy:-) Your comments are a pleasure.
Noraa
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 10:51 pm
maybe this will help, here is a link
brookfield-wi.patch.com/a...
it is from the Patch, a branch of the Huffington Post. Sink reported the numbers at 12:24 the night of the election and yes the EXACT same numbers were talked about in the press conference coming out of Brookfield.
FACE
Sarah Jones
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 12:01 am
Nora, I read that when it came out. That does not address the problems with the election, problems that even Republicans acknowledged and that Kathy Nickolaus has been called to fix long before this election. I’m not sure what your ending word is supposed to imply, but election results in the Supreme Court race were not reliable and do not instill confidence in the process for reasons that have been verified and proven in links I provided. It’s one thing to attempt to add something to a discussion, and another to do it without having read the source material provided and ending with “Face.” I don’t generally grant credence to suggestions accompanied with that sort of attitude.
Barry Roope
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 8:37 am
I think you just crushed that neocon’s illusion about prosser, great job, keep battling these idiots with truth and logic!!
Noraa
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 12:09 pm
Sarah you are right about my prior post ending with attitude, so for that sorry about that. I like to have context with information from all sides, I realize I may not get that here but thats okay.
When discussing vote issues in Waukesha county, remember about Dane county 10,000+ overvote on the same election! Dane like Waukesha had an unusually high voter turnout. The comparisonAlso, this wasn’t like Milwuakee in 2004 when there were over 5000 votes counted more then cast, that election (President) was determined in our state by about 10,000 total. Too bad the same scrutiny wasn’t paid to voting then.
My contribution to fill in details for others who also may want to know.
In total, there were about 1.48 million ballots cast in this election compared to 2.16 million in November. That means that statewide, there was .685 ballots cast for every 1 ballot in November.
The fluctuations by county were significant. Dane county turned out huge…. .83 ballots for every one in November. Union strongholds in northern Wisconsin, Bayfield and Ashland counties were similar…. .82 and .78 ballots in this election relative to November. Milwaukee county was about average at .67
But Prosser got the vote out in many conservative areas… Washington county was above average at .69 and Ozaukee was a respectable .67. But Waukesha county? Its ratio was .587. Only 2 counties in the entire state had a worse turnout relative to November.
Basheert
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 1:27 pm
Great response Sarah. Assault (like sexual harassment) is in the eye of the assaulted. If she felt “assaulted”, or threatened, then she was.
This “judge” has obvious anger issues. He is unfit for office.
As for the commentator, he is not someone I would want on any jury I was on. His bias against women is extreme.
Oldsun
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 4:30 pm
Ah, no Failarron no underage children were involved you fail at that fact. Fact the 17-year-old tweeterer did receive any pictures for Rep Weiner. Next ““found votes” the truth is the numbers reported 20 some hours later matched EXACTLY to the numbers reported that night out of Brookfield”. The whole problem with this statement is that the sign in sheets where in position of the person, who screwed up on the vote count and still does not explain in abnormal increase in voter turnout, so again fail. “The timeline is somewhat strange too isn’t it? An act of violence, choking in a judge’s chambers,” No not strange at all since neither Justice came forward and the “Wisconsin Judicial Commission, which cannot confirm or deny if they are investigating it”. Means that they are in fact investigating it. Again a big fat fail and since there has been things like this said Bitch and that Prosser would destroy her in is in realm of possibility that Prosser would chocker another Justice. So now you know you fail at trolling and at life Auf Wiedersehen!
Sarah Jones
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 4:37 pm
And there were other witnesses to the assault.
Nobody
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 4:37 pm
Funny you should mention underage children and Prosser at the same time. Google Prosser and Feeny.
Sarah Jones
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 4:51 pm
“he called on Prosser to recuse himself from any case involving child abuse.” Nice. Maybe that should also include all cases involving abuse of women.
Jim
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 2:36 am
BRAINS!!!!
Basheert
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 1:30 pm
There were no photos tweeted to “underage children” in the Weiner case. Unlike Mark Foley who tried to diddle pages in the Senate. Or John Ensign who slept with his aide’s wife and paid blackmail. Or David Vitter who wears diapers and plays with prostitutes. Or Larry Craig who trolls bathrooms for gay sex.
The list goes on and on.
The GOP is filled with sexual perverts – and they are openly tolerated by their fellow GOPers.
MsJoanne
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 12:28 am
And if he was black, he’d be in jail and would get no less than five years in prison for assault.
Heather
Jun. 27th, 2011 at 10:46 pm
True conservatives don’t act like that. This man is unfortunately a Supreme Court Justice with a lifetime appointment to that office. Unfortunately you really can’t remove a judge from his office without an act of the divine! They are pretty much above the law and untouchable. It is really sad that people with these middle school mentalities are running our country and making decisions for our welfare. I really don’t think that unless we get away from this idea that we have to choose between a democrat or a republican that we will ever make any really needed changes in our government. We need to step out of the box and start voting our conscience instead of voting for a popularity contest if we want to see any real change. I think it is funny that these people judge the way we act and what we do and they can’t even control themselves. That really sets a poor example for all of our society. Shameful!
Nicole
Jun. 30th, 2011 at 4:45 pm
Again…Any woman who has truely experienced an abusive man knows that there just isn’t something right about her story…And any woman who has truely experienced an abusive man also knows that Bradley choosing this route has only harmed the ability to protect women that have been victims…to Bradley’s won admission to capitol police “He didn’t choke me but he would have if they hadn’t pulled me back” When my ex boyfriend was choking me out it was he not me that needed to be pulled back…Bradley needs to stop helping women…
Sarah Jones
Jun. 30th, 2011 at 5:05 pm
That’s not what she said, and furthermore, 3 other people have come forward to concur with her statement as per the conservative paper that backed Prosser for SC.
This is being investigated right now, so there’s no way that you can know any more than that. Why are you trying to discredit her? If you really are a victim of violence, that’s a horrible thing to do to anyone else, esp knowing nothing about the story.
Reynardine
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 3:44 pm
“Bitch” is no longer, outside of kennel circles, a female dog, nor is it, as formerly, an ill-tempered woman. It has become a term of abuse, like “nigger”, “spic” or “kike”: a term used for a subhuman other who needs to be kept in place and physically abused or even killed if “uppity”. Justitute Prosser has made it clear that this is his view of the half of the human race to which he does not belong.
Sarah Jones
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 5:27 pm
Exactly.
Basheert
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 1:31 pm
I wonder if there isn’t something mentally unsound about Prosser? Granted he is a GOP pig, but his behavior is out of the norm even for Jerky Repubs?
Wise Old Owl
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 5:19 pm
One would think that this disgusting weasel of man would be on his best behavior after managing to steal the recent election. The fact that he feels he can get away with such behavior shows exactly what kind of a person he is, someone who feels he is accountable to no one (except Governor Walker) and least of all the people of Wisconsin.
Basheert
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 1:32 pm
Because no one will get rid of him. The GOP has it locked up in WI…they won’t even charge him. Just watch and see.
Like the 1800′s, he’s going to have to actually kill or injure someone on live TV and even then the Repubs will find a way to defend him.
sherriww
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 5:48 pm
I hate to tell the” justice”,since he does not even seem to know the law,but if you so much as PUT YOUR HAND ON SOMEONE WHO DOES NOT WISH TO BE TOUCHED-THAT IS ASSAULT,AND i had a person arrested for that very thing one time-shoving me and also put their hand on my arm to try to keep me there,to argue further.As part of their getting out of it,an order was issued that they were to stay away from me Permanently!It is quite a shame that this man is not in jail as we speak!
Reynardine
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 7:41 pm
Well, Airhead, a couple of rules for retaining your law license and your bench is that you don’t call your chief justice a bitch (or a son therof), and you don’t commit a battery on a justice. The former, at a minimum, is contempt of court. At common law and under most statutes, an intentional and unwanted touching is a battery, and the difference between grabbing the justice by her shoulders and attempting to throttle her is the difference between a simple and an aggravated battery. Some jurisdictions class this kind of attack as a severer degree of assault, but in any juridiction, it’s a crime. Committing a battery against a fellow justice to attempt to make her change her vote is probably a few federal offenses, as well. Meanwhile, you talk as if you were a fly on the wall, but that is dubious. It sounds more like your fly needs swatting.
Basheert
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 1:33 pm
The woman has obviously chosen to cover this up. Can this be reported to, and investigated by the Wisconsin Bar? Since the DA probably won’t touch it, and the Judiciary Committee is rampant with GOP nuts?
tonitdown
Jun. 25th, 2011 at 9:39 pm
Our system is in breakdown. The divisive nature of the debate– between these justices, between the comments here on this article, and between right and left in the nation– prevents progress. This incident started as a debate on collective bargaining, but it quickly deteriorated into irrational ideology. We are seeing conflict lead to impasse at every level, from talk-radio to Congress.
Please note this observation when you think about the debate:
Our country is deteriorating badly. Look back over the last 40 years, dominated by Republican policy control for more than 3/4 of that time, and see how our nation has dropped in world standings for education, healthcare and longevity. USA used to rank in the top 5 of every category, now it is not even in top 20. For many of us, our kids will not live as long as we will. Broken.
Jim
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 2:57 am
AM airwaves have become the GOP megaphone and should go back to top 40, they would make more sense. What GOP announcers call “mainstream media” they are now are a part of. Back in the day, if you weren’t mainstream, you were deemed “underground”.
bob dobson
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 7:03 am
www.jsonline.com/news/wis...
Bradley has made a statement saying that Prosser choked her. I especially like this line: “Those are the facts and you can try to spin those facts and try to make it sound like I ran up to him and threw my neck into his hands, but that’s only spin.”
Violent and escalating. So, at the very least, he should recuse himself from any cases where participants include women. Or when any of the participants are related to women.
Noraa
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 12:28 pm
www.wisn.com/news/2835831...
I especially like witness reports “Prosser was actually defending himself during the incident. That source said Prosser was in an office with Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson and Ann Walsh Bradley when Prosser said he had lost confidence in Abrahamson’s leadership. According to the source, Bradley then lunged at Prosser.”
Through a spokesman, Prosser issued a statement Saturday evening saying, “Once there’s a proper review of this matter, and the facts surrounding it are made clear, the anonymous claim made to the media will be proven false. Until then, I will refrain from further public comment.”
Also Bob, The large amount of money directly linked to unions and Abrahamson from her recent campaign… she definately should have recused herself from ruling on the collective bargaining bill.
Reynardine
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 12:37 pm
Sorry, Noraa. You’re Aaron spelled backwards. You’re busted. Also, you’re still an airhead and your fly still needs swatting.
Noraa
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 2:09 pm
Posting links, and facts with commentary makes me an airhead? Why not comment on subject matter? Yes there are witnesses to the incident, but not providing all accounts is leaving other readers to be airheads.. is it so bad to know that others described Prosser to be acting in defense while being attacked?
As to the fly being on the wall, needing to be swatted, I think your statement reflects the idea that information needs to be supressed, if it is not in support of you ideology.
Reynardine
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 2:16 pm
I think specious liars and impersonators need to be swatted. And you never denied you’re Aaron, did you. Now go home, you moron sock puppet, and check those buggers you pasted to the wall. They should be about crunchy enough to eat.
Basheert
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 1:35 pm
Thanks for that link. The problem is, she should have issued that statement immediately. Rather than hide, and let everyone play coverup – she should have immediately spoken up and DEMANDED an investigation.
Let’s hope her statement yesterday will force a BAR examination.
ummmm, what?!
Jun. 26th, 2011 at 4:37 pm
Why is his face crooked? Did it have to do with the choking?
DannyEastVillage
Jun. 27th, 2011 at 7:05 am
Typical of conservatives to defend the indefensible. When they want to steal no action is too ugly.
Craig
Jul. 2nd, 2011 at 9:43 am
Why is it Republicans always the first to respond to a situation with physical violence?
Is something wrong with the chemical balance of their brains?