Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
The Most Religious Red States Also Consume the Most Antidepressants
For much of the world’s population, religious belief systems inform their world view by relating humanity to spirituality and, more often than not, to values that give meaning to life by providing adherents morality, ethics, and directions for their preferred lifestyle. In America, forty percent of the population considers themselves very religious, and they claim, without apology, that their worldview and reason for living derives from their strict adherence to Christianity; the primary religion in this country. It should come as no surprise that the most religious regions of the country are located in southern states, and a recent poll revealed that, indeed, except for Utah (56%), well over 50% of the population in Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana, Arkansas, Tennessee, the Carolinas, and Oklahoma consider themselves to be very religious, and they are very depressed.
In a study conducted between 2000 and 2006 by a large pharmaceutical manufacturer, they discovered that the most religious states have the highest percentage of the population using some kind of anti-depressant drug. The comprehensive study focused on the implications and numerous challenges of managing prescription drug costs, and they focused on the “sociodemographic forces influencing the use of prescription drugs,” but they did not examine the role religion plays in the higher-than-average use of anti-depressants. It is quite possible, and likely, that “very religious” Christians are having difficulty reconciling their Christ-centered beliefs with the direction American Christianity is going, and the conflicts inherent with adhering to archaic knowledge and understanding of the world while living in the 21st century where science and empirical data contradicts the superstitious and antiquated “facts” contained in the Christian bible.
Faith in Christ is supposed to be succor to the afflicted, and give hope to his followers that living a life of charity and love for all human kind is the path to happiness now and earns the reward of life eternal in Christ’s presence in Heaven. However, the trend among many Christians is rejecting the tenets of Christ’s message for harsh Old Testament edicts meant to instill fear and guilt endemic to disobeying god’s laws instead of love of neighbor, and it must affect the mental state of adherents struggling to reconcile Christ’s love with the Old Testament message of an angry and wrathful “god of love.” It is no wonder the “very religious” are depressed when they read in their bible that Christ commanded the rich to give away all their belongings to the poor to enter into Heaven, and yet their clergy preach support of politicians who take from the poor to give to the rich. Are they compensating for their religious dilemma by resorting to chemicals to assuage the misery of disobeying their lord and savior, Jesus Christ, or dulling the guilt from causing suffering on their fellow Americans?
Most of the political and cultural positions of highly religious states give the appearance that unless Christians force their Old Testament sensibilities featuring intolerance, hatred, and retribution for non-compliance with god’s laws on the rest of America, they are doomed to burn in everlasting fire. And yet, they read in scripture that Jesus commanded them to treat their enemies and non-believers with peace and love, and lacking fortitude to challenge the clergy’s contradictions, it is just as easy to stay sedate to mask their internal conflict as they support the proliferation of guns, treating women as slaves, and punishing gays; many of them fellow Christians.
It is also possible they require anti-depressants to balance the constant state of fear, rage, and antipathy for science and knowledge that belies the bible’s explanation of the universe and its contention the Earth and its inhabitants were created 10,000 years ago. In a poll conducted in July, 2012, forty-six percent of Americans confirmed their belief in the creationist view that God made the Universe, Earth and human beings in their present form at one time within the last 10,000 years despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary and absolutely no proof of the bible’s explanation. What is astonishing is that there are seemingly intelligent, university-educated Christians who go into a rage if their creation myth is challenged, and when any high-school sophomore presents incontestable proof they are misinformed, the realization that everything they learned from the bible, the clergy, and church is false must engender overwhelming depression. Take, for example, the case of Mormons who are generally highly educated and still cling to a mid-nineteenth century story that high school geography, history, and archeology proves is absolutely false, and it makes sense that Utah residents are as highly medicated with anti-depressants as any uber-religious Southern state.
Religion, although strange to a secular Humanist, does have redeeming value for millions of Americans in that it gives them comfort that there is something other than this wondrous life. However, throughout the history of the Christian religion, it has wrought death and destruction on those who choose not to follow it and that is a sad commentary on a religion allegedly based in tolerance, love, and humanity. To learn that its adherents resort to using chemicals to allay their depressive state, regardless the reason, is sadder still and worse, is of their own making. Every Christian knows that Jesus Christ’s message is contrary to their ideology of intolerance, hate, and greed, and that they have benefitted immensely from science they deride in clinging to Stone Age mythology. No-one denies them their beliefs, or faith, if they need it to direct their morality, but if they are so conflicted they need anti-depressants to cope, perhaps it is time they examine either their religion, or their practice thereof, because there are bad men in the clergy and politics using their depression, and sedate mental state, to inflict harm on the rest of population that Jesus would never condone; but there are few Christians listening to Jesus these days.
Today tens-of-millions of Americans will tune in and watch the Super Bowl, and it is certain that most o ...
All around the world today, multitudes of Christians are celebrating their opportunity for salvation and ...
Throughout recorded history, religion has been responsible for the most hideous crimes against humanity. ...
Every religion revolves around some significant story that is integral to their belief system, and during th ...
Around the world there are only a handful of countries that self-identify strongly with a religion as th ...
Zarrakan
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 9:00 am
Fake things do not give real comfort. Religion is one of the worst kinds of preferential thinking. I made a video about education in which I talk about it, and other real threats affecting education. It’s at my YouTube channel Zarrakan, and here’s the name:
2012 8 25 ZOC Education
www.youtube.com/watch?v=I...
Watch it, share it, and join the fight against people who wrongfully blame individual failure on educators.
Hrafnkell Haraldsson
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 9:05 am
You almost have to admire their dogged perseverance in the face of our shared reality, Muse. Their steadfast refusal to see where their bigotry leads them away from Jesus is breathtaking, as is their claim to be Christians at all when they’ve thrown Jesus not just out the window, but under the bus, and then backed over him a few times.
Sandra
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 5:12 pm
Most would not be able to define what Christianity is. It’s one thing to refer to oneself as a Christian but real Christians follow the Words/Teachings and Commandments of Jesus Christ which these people do not. Ergo, they are not Christians because they are not followers of Christ. They don’t seem to realise that the Old Testament is pre Christ is separate from the New Testament eg.the OT talks about an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, Jesus tells to turn the other cheek in the NT and the importance of forgiveness, tolerance, love of each other, helping the poor, feeding the hungry, clothing the naked. His teachings were about empathy, sympathy, loving and treating each other as we would expect to be loved and treated and the brotherhood of man. I blame alot of their confusion and anger and hate on their false prophets which Jesus told us to be aware of.”Beware of false prophets preaching in My Name.”
jacqsprat
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 7:39 pm
You are a touch ignorant on what the “OLD testament” (as you call it) teaches.
I find the Hebrew testament full of grace.
Please refrain from making judgements on something outside your own faith. I found Jews MUCH more gracious and kind in their faith than Christians!!
‘New Testament’ Christians believe that their loving God will torture all non followers in an eternal fire !! Seriously – Jews don’t believe this nonsense and are shocked you attribute such horrors to their God!
Look in your own backyard! (Log speck eye)
leviticus 19
“‘Do not seek revenge or bear a grudge against one of your people, but love your neighbor as yourself. I am the LORD.
Do not say, “I will repay evil”; Wait for the LORD, and He will save you. (Proverbs 20:22)
“They refused to listen… But You are a God of forgiveness, Gracious and compassionate, Slow to anger and abounding in loving kindness; And You did not forsake them. (Nehemiah 9:17)
But You, O Lord, are a God merciful and gracious, Slow to anger and abundant in loving kindness and truth. (Psalm 86:15)
For NO ONE (note NO ONE) is cast off
by the Lord forever.
32 Though he brings grief, he will show compassion,
so great is his UNFAILING LOVE.
33 For he does not willingly bring affliction
or grief to anyone.(lamentation 3)
Shiva(Moderator)
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 8:00 pm
Dont call someone ignorant when you are basing your opinion against their opinion then start quoting scripture. Its unseemly
jacqsprat
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 8:20 pm
Dear Moderator. Who cannot be replied to (convenient). Thus I reply here
Please note
1: Please note the term “a TOUCH ignorant” then the following word “on”. Thus I did not making the generalisation that one was categorically ignorant.
2: The scipture was making one aware that the Hebrew testament does preach the smae as Jesus regarding forgiveness and compassion.
It would be silly to make this claim without showing the evidence there of!
jacqsprat
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 8:26 pm
responding again to your comment. (any reason it was removed?)
Please note in my reply the words “touch ignorant” and the following word “on”… thus not fair to claim I accused the post-er of being categorically ignorant.
Also it would be wrong of me to claim that the Hebrew testament does teach forgiveness and mercy and compassion yet not back it up!
please leave my response as i have a right of reply and it is unethical to deny my this right on a PUBLIC forum!
Shiva(Moderator)
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 8:30 pm
Your comment is not removed.
The hierarchy of comments only goes so deep then you cant answer. Most anyone can see that
Lastly, you have a right to nothing on other peoples property.
RMuse
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 8:57 pm
Ignorance is relative. Christ came, fulfilled, and ended the Mosaic Law (covenant with Israel), Christians are not bound by Law. The Hebrew Scriptures contain some of the most violent expressions of a “loving god” imaginable that far outweigh any conveyance of love, and compassion is reserved for strict obedience that often included murdering men, women, children, slaves and animals. In most cases, forgiveness followed harsh discipline and dire suffering if not annihilation. Further, Christians are not bound by Jewish Law…unless they are America’s neo-Christians.
Gemster
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 9:34 am
Why assume that it is the religious people taking the meds? I find it equally likely that they are driving their non-Christian neighbors, read victims, to need sedation.
Reynardine
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 10:09 am
Gemster, I don’t have to assume. I can see it.
I live in a highly-mixed county of the highly-mixed state of Florida, and I know a good many people of different religious persuasions. Though illness itself is no respecter of persons (albeit a constantly gloomy state of mind predisposes to illness, and vice versa), it is people who belong to the more punitive religions who are popping the most mood pills. This is especially true of women, who have been taught that a servile life is the proper punishment for that repulsive, yet sinfully magnetic, thing between their legs. It is these women, also, constantly brought down by chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia, who never have a pleasant thing to say about life. I don’t doubt that being in a constant state of self-loathing and self-punishment causes autoimmune responses.
Gemster
Feb. 18th, 2013 at 10:49 am
Reynardine – I happen to live in a very republican/religious county in one of the most republican/religious states in the country. Here in South Carolina politics and religion are prevalent and lean heavily toward the republican/religious right.
While I don’t doubt that religious women take their fair share of antidepressants I still maintain that it’s likely not the defining factor.
A cursory search of the internet turns up that the top five states for antidepressant use are not only republican and religious but are also in the highest rankings for poverty, violent crime and gun death while placing in the bottom in the areas of health and education.
All-in-all, these states have a lot more to be depressed about than religion.
Shiva(Moderator)
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:03 am
The non christians dont have the stress of worrying about not getting to heaven
Gemster
Feb. 18th, 2013 at 10:52 am
Honestly, neither do Southern Christians. They are very confident that they are heading to heaven regardless of their behavior.
Troy Kempton
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 10:37 am
This goes a long way in explaining a number of things but it sure would be nice to know the back-up and resources you used in this article, otherwise it’s just conjecture and regarded as hearsay by those who need to hear it most. Unlike most of my fellow Independents and Democrats I openly debate Conservatives and even the best fact-deniers get worn down when you can support your arguments with meat and potatoes.
djchefron(Moderator)
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:03 am
Here you go
America’s Most Medicated States
www.forbes.com/2009/08/17...
TraceyP
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:38 am
That Forbes article refers to ALL meds, not just mental drugs. Most of the drugs in that report are heart meds to Medicare (retired) people.
Try again.
djchefron(Moderator)
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:53 am
Yes the article takes into account all drugs but it included drugs for mental health.But even if you want to argue semantics it still points to the fact that people in red states are some of the biggest moochers of government programs that the teabaggers decry.And if you think that the people who are on private insurance are the majority then you just dont want to face facts.
We can agree that Utah is very religious,right.Then explain this
Study Finds Utah Leads Nation in Antidepressant Use
articles.latimes.com/2002...
Here is a study in PDF from 2007/When you read into it you will find that in the bottom 10 only one is a Progressive state.
Ranking America’s Mental Health:
An Analysis of Depression Across the States
www.nmha.org/files/Rankin...
Le Jane
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:03 am
Has it occurred to you that perhaps it is those of us who are not religious but who are for various reasons stuck here in these places who are consuming the anti-depressants? :-)
djchefron(Moderator)
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:06 am
I don’t speak for the author but maybe its cause and effect.I live in the reddest state in America and I’m tempted to get high on something legal or illegal
mary adkins
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:12 am
I’m not sure if it is the actual religious beliefs of some that drive them into a depressive state. In fact people I know who really believe the teachings of Jesus ie; kindness to all, doing good deeds, seem pretty happy. However, I’ve noticed many more depressed people in the south, who have had “old time religion” shoved down their throats as young people. They seem to also be ambivalent about religion. These same folks see women as inferior, anyone different than they are as “bad or threatening”. It may just be a mindset or herd mentality. If they truly believed the actual teachings of Jesus, I don’t think they’d be as bitter or miserable toward others. Thats just my theory and opinion.
Vvixen
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 11:24 am
The Southern states are also the poorest states in the country, where even full-time workers are paid poverty wages and there is no social safety net to speak of. I think it’s just as likely that chronic, generational poverty drives both the interest in fundamentalist religion and the depression that leads to self-medication with anti-depressants. Women with children are the poorest of the poor in these states, with the least social supports and they are the most powerless to change their circumstances. Is it any wonder that there is an epidemic of depression and autoimmune diseases among women of reproductive age in these states? My sister-in-law, a beautiful, well-educated woman, developed chronic fatigue syndrome after her traditional marriage to a fundamentalist man and three children didn’t lead to the happiness and fulfillment she was taught to expect. They eventually got divorced and her depression and chronic fatigue miraculously disappeared! But unfortunately, he also took the house and the youngest child and left her in poverty. She is still happier and healthier now that she is rid of him, but it’s unfortunate that marriages like that can’t be prevented in the first place. It would save the health care system a lot of money, and we’d have a much healthier population of women, but maybe then the Southern men wouldn’t be as happy. Let them suffer the depression & chronic fatigue!
Dr Billy Kidd
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 5:42 pm
I will quote the report recited in this article. The author misrepresents the South in a big way. Look at the facts about anti-depressants:
“Three of the five states with the highest
rate of use in 2000 — Utah, Maine and
Kentucky — remained in the top five in
2006. Although Utah continued to be the
state with the highest prevalence of
antidepressant use, it had one of the lowest
rate increases of any state (2.4%) between
2000 and 2006. States with the greatest
increases in overall prevalence included the
Southeastern states of Alabama and Louisiana,
in addition to states located in the Northern
(Wisconsin) and Northeastern (New
Hampshire and Connecticut) regions of
the country.”
This article by Rmuse gets awarded Four Flatulants: Mostly False. Please don’t take this personal, folks. Read the original article that is cited and remenber, I ususally vote up on Rmuse!
phooeyrat
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 6:11 pm
I was raised from scratch in the small Spanish mission city of San Juan Bautista California. In grade school all us kids were given the choice to attend religious training, on school time, off school grounds, ounce a week from the religion of our choice, either Catholic or Protestant or just remain on the school grounds and take a long recess period until the rest of the religious kids returned from their specific church that they were being indoctrinated in. Since many of the good looking girls and a lot of my close friends and family members were Catholic (some friends served as alter boys). I chose the Catholic religion. I remember being told in our weekly Catholicism classes (taught by the local nuns and priest at the mission) that if we were to die with a “mortal” sin on our souls that we would not go to heaven but go to hell instead. We were all told that not attending church (mass) on Sunday was a mortal sin and the only way to have the mortal sin removed was to go to the priest and confess your sins to him so that he could absolve you of this sin and make your soul pure and acceptable to God again. Impure thoughts were considered not as bad as mortal sins but still had to be confessed to the priest. I tried not to sin but could not handle all the guilt trips and the church’s scheduling of my life to meet their standards; which I failed to do. I have not attended a mass or given a confession to a priest (who is only a mere mortal like all the rest of us; in my opinion) since leaving grade school. However; I must “confess” that when my son was born I felt the strong need to have him baptized (I was baptized) which is still today a standard practice in most Christian religions. I went to my base military Catholic chaplains office to arrange it. I was told by the chaplain that since my wife was not a Catholic that they would not perform the baptism of my son until she was. I stated to him that I was taught in Catholicism if my son should die with out being baptized that he would not be able to enter heaven because he would still have “original-sin” on his soul. He told me that had “changed” now; don’t worry and get my wife converted to be a Catholic and they would then baptize my son. I left the chapel and baptized my son myself. If I am guilty of being a sinner so be it. What kind of insane con games are the religions of the world playing on us mere mortals? These games should be considered as not only crimes against humanity but sins committed on a grand scale against God. In my opinion. The Pope himself called it quits and he is supposed to be in direct contact with God at all times. I’m confused. And we allow them the churches to have tax exempt status. I need to take a “smoke” break now to relieve some stress. I wont tell you guys exactly what it is that I’m smoking but it sure helps me deal with a lot of the “bull-shit” in life like this. In my opinion. Be good!
john r
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 8:22 pm
of course these same states rate highest in pornography consumption
Shiva(Moderator)
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 8:30 pm
Utah for one
Evermore Jones
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 9:36 pm
Speaking to the point of mental illness. How come christians can have an imaginary friend but its wrong for children to have one? It’s a question I’ve been wondering about for a long time.
Elizabeth 44
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 9:41 pm
What is left out is the lifestyle the women live in a “traditional” marriage. First: no birth control. If God gives you 10 kids, so be it. Second: It is “in” to raise most of the family’s food. Women and children’s work. Third: all cooking done at home, including grinding grains; all sewing done at home; and of course,usual housework. Fourth: all children homeschooled by mother. Fifth: income is usually limited so there is a constant pressure to make the money stretch. Sixth: all women are to be cheerful handmaidens of the Lord with perfect children. In other words, there is always someone at church to criticize your personal and children’s failings. Are you ready for the anti-depressant yet? If interested, I commend to your reading: the blog: No longer quivering; and the blog Freedom from Mormonism.
inez
Feb. 17th, 2013 at 10:16 pm
Considering the states involved in this study, I”d rather refer to the meds as repressants, not anti depressants.Take enough of that stuff and you don’t care about the governance, or much else. How many are gun owners??????????????????
SinghX
Feb. 18th, 2013 at 9:19 am
“Any frontal attack on ignorance is bound to fail because the masses are always ready to defend their most precious possession–their ignorance.”
Hendrick Willem Van Loon, Dutch-American journalist
(1882-1944).
Youjo Ripper
Feb. 21st, 2013 at 9:59 pm
I live in LA, and I know more people on ADs, then not. I was on them, too.