Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
Romney’s Tax Plan Turns the Laws of Mathematics on their Head
By: Hrafnkell HaraldssonOct. 16th, 2012more from Hrafnkell Haraldsson

It is fitting that the New York Times refers to a ”reality-based community” because it was in the New York Times that this now famous phrase first appeared, back in 2004, quoting, fittingly enough, a Republican. It was an aide to President George W. Bush who first put a Republican president outside of reality and bragged about the expediency of making his own. And this is a community from which Mitt Romney has also willingly excluded himself.
“Blue-sky promises” hits the nail on the head. We are going to fix this and fix that, Romney says, but he won’t - and can’t - say how. It’s like magic (after all, Ann says, just electing him will fix everything – who needs math?) and we’re just supposed to trust him. I wouldn’t trust Romney if he told me the sky was blue.
Watch whichmitt.com and tell me you can trust this man. My hunch is that Rmuse was right to question Mitt’s mental health the other day.
As the Times go on to tell us: “The latest is the Joint Committee on Taxation, an obscure but well-respected Congressional panel — currently evenly divided between the parties — that helps lawmakers calculate the effect of their tax plans.”
And what is the word, you ask? It’s another blow to wishful thinking:
The answer came last week: ending all those deductions would only produce enough revenue to lower tax rates by 4 percent. Mitt Romney says he can lower tax rates by 20 percent and pay for it by ending deductions. The joint committee’s math makes it clear that that is impossible.
That won’t stop Mr. Romney from insisting that it is possible when he debates President Obama, of course, though he won’t have Lehrer in his corner this time.
We have already seen how Paul Ryan handled these questions when Mike Wallace put him on the spot on Fox News of all places.
Yet it was Romney who told Obama he was not entitled to his own reality. That was a brilliant stroke, taking the initiative. You have to admire anyone willing to lie so boldly and so confidently. But with Mike Wallace, and with developments like the Times editorial, the tide me be beginning to turn on Romney’s fantasy economics. President Obama has the chance to put this lie away at the upcoming debate.
You don’t have to go far, though, to see how widespread this denial-of-reality goes, and why even a splash of cold ocean won’t shake the devotion of the faithful.
Glenn Beck may be less visible these days but he’s no less over-the-top. When you get a mythologizer like David Barton together with the suggestible and highly-strung Beck, anything can happen. Like proclaiming that Mitt Romney is the next Abraham Lincoln.
The Great Enslaver is like the Great Emancipator?
Glenn, you’re known for saying some crazy things, but are you sure you want to go there?
Take a look courtesy of Right Wing Watch:
David Barton says it was Lincoln’s proclamation of a day of prayer and fasting on March 30, 1863 that gave the Union the win. Apparently, “God” decided that rather than giving the Union the win right then and there as a reward, he’d make them fight for another bloody two years and let tens of thousands of young men die horribly along with the suffering of an often innocent civilian population in the war zones.
Right. And Thomas Jefferson could not have freed his slaves. Look, the war was won because of a number of factors, not least Lincoln’s tenacity and 23,000 dead and wounded and missing at Gettysburg who exhibited a tenacity of their own in the cause of the Union. If Barton’s god won the Civil War, he had a sick way of doing it.
These two topics may seem unrelated but they’re tightly entwined. The fundamentalist Republican base wants a certain America. To have that certain America, they need a certain past. Romney wants to have a certain America too – namely an America with him at the head. To have that, certain things have to be true even when they cannot possibly be. Like this recent Romney ad attacking Obama. As lies go, this is nothing less than breathtaking:
“The facts are clear. Obama’s four deficits are the four largest in U.S. history. He’s adding almost as much debt as all 43 previous presidents combined.”
Not only did 9/11 now happen on Obama’s watch, but George W. Bush’s debt now magicaly becomes Obama’s debt. Do the math. Romney sure didn’t.
The Republican War on Science has tossed aside all appeal to facts, to reality, to cause and effect, and to the historical record.
Really, with all due respect to the New York Times, it is not a working calculator Romney needs at all. What Romney needs, what the Republican Party as a whole needs, is a willingness to use a calculator. It’s almost as though such things have come to be seen as the workings of Satan, and we can only wonder how long it will be before we are being told that microphones and cameras steal the soul.
Anything that casts doubt on the Republican Party’s fantasy America must be the work of demons.
The Times sums up the situation nicely: “It is increasingly clear that the Romney tax ‘plan’ is not really a plan at all but is instead simply a rhapsody based on old Republican themes that something can be had for nothing.
Including a new history and indeed, new mathematical laws, and new laws of physics, more amenable to their fantasies.
We have many mathematical laws but the most important law in all of history might be Romney’s Law, which supersedes everything you thought you knew: that numbers are and do what you insist they are and do.
Let the voter beware.
Photo from Robert Pielke Jr.’s Blog
Paul Ryan welcomed himself to the Romney campaign by claiming on 60 Minutes that he wants to eliminate t ...
The Republican Vice Presidential candidate Paul Ryan was on Fox News showing off his alleged wonk skills ...
Mitt Romney finally took the stage in Boston to let Republicans know that the delusion is dead. The ange ...
While her husband is blaming 'you people' for his loss, Ann Romney is blaming the media for Mitt Romney' ...
On Fox News Sunday today, Mitt Romney blamed minorities for costing him the election, and poor people wh ...
clarence swinney
Oct. 16th, 2012 at 8:53 am
Second Fact Check On Spending
The last budget of Bush spent 3510B
Actual spent in fiscal 2012 was 3540.
The 2013 budget projects spending at 3800B.
That indicates that Obama will increase spending
from 3510 to 3800 or 8.3% for four years.
Compare to Reagan 80% and Bush 90% (1830 to 3510)
One big problem is failure to tax to get revenue to pay our way
thereby creating the horrid debt burden.
In fiscal 2012 we borrowed 1100B. A shame. While corporations made record profits and richest got much richer. We have the income to pay our way.
The revenue in fiscal 2012 was 2450B is why we rank below only Chile and Mexico as Least Taxed in OECD nations. The 2450 is 17% of our National Income.
Runaway unfunded spending is in Medicare and Pentagon.
We must cut the runaway spending and tax wealth more to start paying down the debt.
Colleen
Oct. 16th, 2012 at 9:19 am
I guess in his eyes eliminating deductions doesn’t amount to a tax increase, but in my eyes it means that the middle class will be paying more to support the already millionaires. Of course congress would be in favor of this because they majority of them fall into that group.
harris stein
Oct. 16th, 2012 at 1:31 pm
“The fundamentalist Republican base wants a certain America. To have that certain America, they need a certain past.”
That’s it in a nutshell. But you can’t rewrite history. And the history of the US is of a secular nation where government and religion are like apples and oranges. You can slice and dice them and mix them up in a salad but you still have a salad with its separate parts. Only after the salad is consumed does it become blended into 1 thing. And a few hours after that it turns into well, ……. you know what it turns into.
Prior to the Civil War the Democrats in the south tried to have it both ways by rewriting history. They quoted the Bible and the US Constitution to justify slavery and its expansion into the western territories. The Whigs and Republicans would have none of this. Now it’s the republicans and the evangelical fundies trying to rewrite history. My, how things have changed.
Inez
Oct. 16th, 2012 at 8:30 pm
i can’t understand how many people have been hoodwinked by, as i call it, mittshit. it is unfathonable that intellegent people have regarded all of his lies as factual. this man scares me and hope that all good people will come to the aid of their party and vote for democrats across the board……..
Lynda Harrison
Oct. 19th, 2012 at 12:42 pm
Good comment, Inez, but my question is – are you quite sure that anyone who believes what you describe as MITTSHIT are intelligent? This specimen has lied and contradicted himself so many times that I don’t believe anyone with any intelligence could possibly give any credibility to anything he says, let alone give him the honor of their vote.