Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
Scott Walker Gets Schooled on the Constitution; Collective Bargaining Law Struck Down
By: Sarah JonesSep. 14th, 2012more from Sarah Jones
As we have discussed here ever since Governor Scott Walker attacked collective bargaining rights in Wisconsin, he was violating both the state and US constitution’s guarantee of free speech and free association. The state constitution has further protections for collective bargaining that Walker and the Republicans ignored in drafting and passing their egregious law (known as Act 10) meant to kill collective bargaining.
Well, the courts finally caught up with Walker’s ridiculous attempt to appease the Koch Brothers and other donors, and they agree. Dane County Circuit Court Judge Juan Colás (appointed by Jim Doyle (D)) struck down the essential parts of the 2011 law Wisconsin Republicans passed in the dark of night without a quorum. Collective bargaining rights are restored for city, county, and school workers.
The Wisconsin State Journal reported:
Ruling in a lawsuit brought by Madison Teachers Inc. and a union representing public workers in Milwaukee, Circuit Judge Juan B. Colas said in a 27-page decision that sections of the law “single out and encumber the rights of those employees who choose union membership and representation solely because of that association and therefore infringe upon the rights of free speech and association.”
Colas also said that the law violates the constitutional equal protection clause by creating separate classes of state workers who are treated differently and unequally under the law.
Governor Walker having his signature legislation tossed out as unconstitutional is rather delicious, with conservatives pretending to care so much about the constitution. Of course this won’t be the the end of Walker’s efforts to destroy freedom. He will appeal to the Supreme Court.
In March, District Judge William M. Conley overruled recertification requirements for some public-employee unions but not all, again due to Walker treating different unions differently under the law. Conley wrote, “This is not an ordinary case in any number of respects, but it is ordinary in the sense that political favoritism is no grounds for heightened scrutiny under the Equal Protection clause” of the U.S. Constitution.
Hard to argue against equal protection and freedom of assembly and claim you are FOR freedom, but somehow Walker and his Republican cronies manage to sell this to their easily manipulated base.
Walker’s base shouldn’t fret though, as Walker is hardly done wasting millions advancing his radical agenda even when it violates freedoms protected in the US Constitution. He will waste plenty more taxpayer dollars in his pursuit before he’s shown the door.
The brave citizens of Wisconsin were correct back in 2011, and though they had to wait a long time for Lady Justice, she arrived today. Now the state is stuck figuring out what this means for the bargaining that’s taken place since the law was passed, and wading through yet another epic disaster courtesy of Scott Walker, whose similar attempt as County Executive was also found to violate the law and cost the state 4.5 million additional dollars.
Wasting millions to advance a purely political agenda? That’s the new “fiscal conservative” Republican for you.
A new Wisconsin Policy Research Institute poll released today revealed that by trying to break the publi ...
Governor Walker and the Republican leadership found a way around the quorum needed to pass Walker's death ...
What is happening in Wisconsin and Ohio isn't about wages and benefits, like those on the conservative r ...
Governor Scott Walker issued a statement today about the mass shootings at a Wisconsin Sikh Temple this ...
As saner Republican governors see just how much heat is raining down on upon unilateral tyrant Republica ...
rodeodance
Sep. 14th, 2012 at 9:31 pm
Wisconsin Defender @wi_defender
What’s the name of the Eagle Scout badge they give out for immediately disparaging the integrity of any judge that rules against you?
mjh
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 3:26 pm
The “Activist Judges” badge . . .
.
buckeyewill
Sep. 14th, 2012 at 10:00 pm
WOW…justice flowing down like mighty waters.
Dorie Mae
Sep. 14th, 2012 at 11:32 pm
This is indeed wonderful news, but one has to remember that the Wisconsin Supreme Court is stacked in Walker’s favor. They never let him down–and he knows it. One can rejoice for the moment, but Walker seems to always get what he wants. The damage he has done to Wisconsin will outlast him.
Alan
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 11:14 am
Since this case involves violation of the US Constitution as well as that of the state of Wisconsin, it’s entirely possible that when the Wisconsin Supreme Court (a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Tea Party) overrules this judge, an appeal to the US Supreme Court could happen.
joseph falco
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 1:15 pm
…then its onward through the Federal Courts until it reaches the Supreme Court
D. W. Skinner
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 12:26 am
don’t worry… it will all get undone… The republicans have ruined their brand… 2010 was their last hurrah… if they survive after this election it will be a miracle..
Mike Roesch
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 8:25 am
Mental Midgets such as Scott Walker will have their day of attonent . It may take some time but the public will get fed up with his horseshit.
NativeSonKY
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 12:53 pm
Now if we could just get some of those union printing jobs down here in Kentucky! But I ain’t holding my breath for sure! Good to see some progress though for sure!
Anne
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 1:11 pm
It’s great to see Scott Walker get a well-earned smackdown, but I will rest easy only when any subsequent appeals on his part are denied by the Wisconsin Supreme Court, and the US Supreme Court if push comes to shove. A rejection of his appeals would also be a smackdown for the even more sociopathic Koch brothers whose bidding he willingly does.
Inez
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 10:49 pm
You can help to defeat Ryan as well…see my post
MiserableOldFart
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 1:29 pm
I am still livid at the people of Wisconsin for not putting this piece of trash out of office. I hope this ruling stands, but we need to get the right wing fascist garbage out of our government. They are a menace to our country and the world.
mjh
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 4:24 pm
Man — it has been a baaad couple of months for the wingnuts, where the judiciary has been concerned.
First, the Supreme Court struck down most of Arizona SB 1070 {and the part they left standing, the “show your papers” provision, could be struck down in the future} . . . then, they upheld the ACA — which led some wingnuts to ask if it was time for armed rebellion . . . now this . . .
.
Inez
Sep. 15th, 2012 at 10:47 pm
As a former Union officer for years,I was so dismayed over this arbitrary decision to prohibit Union negotiations, I sent a check to the Wisconsin Dems to fight Walker! Let’s hope that Walker’s appeal will be rejected!!!!!!I also sent them acheck recently to defeat Paul Ryan who is on the ballot for Congress. I”d welcome a double defeat so he can get a real job!