Go to Admin » Appearance » Widgets » and move Gabfire Widget: Social into that MastheadOverlay zone
Texas Declares War on UN Vote Monitors
more from Hrafnkell Haraldsson
Reuters reported yesterday that Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott has warned the OCSE to stay away from Texas polling places. I wrote the other day about the Republican reaction to the presence of these international observers. The agents of voter suppression to not want witnesses to their illegal activities.
So in a move that is likely to be repeated in other Red States, Abbott says he will take legal action if the OCSE refuses to follow state law. Not federal law, mind you, but state law. The treaty in question, of course, was not made by the State of Texas, but by the United States of America.
Abbott said,
“They act like they may not be subject to Texas law and our goal all along is to make clear to them that when they’re in Texas, they’re subject to Texas law, and we’re not giving them an exemption.”
He claims, “Our concern is that this isn’t some benign observation but something intended to be far more prying and maybe even an attempt to suppress voter integrity.”
Only in Texas, is the subtitle here. These Red States sometimes forget we are a nation, a union of states under a single federal government and that individual states do not make foreign policy decisions, sign treaties, or decide which obligations to adhere to. You might be able to ignore biblical injunctions at will but states can’t ignore international treaties.
So Abbott sent a letter to the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) and told them that OSCE vote monitors were not allowed by Texas state law to enter polling places:
“While it remains unclear exactly what your monitoring is intended to achieve, or precisely what tactics you will use to achieve the proposed monitoring, OSCE has stated publicly that it will visit polling stations on Election Day as part of its monitoring plan.”
Abbott’s letter included a warning:
“It may be a criminal offense for OSCE’s representatives to maintain a presence within 100 feet of a polling place’s entrance. Failure to comply with these requirements could subject the OSCE’s representatives to criminal prosecution for violating state law.”
You can almost hear his outrage: “Now, how the hell are we gonna suppress them darkies and greasers from voting if we got the UN watchin’?”
In a tweet, he did what Texans always seem to do, and drew a comparison with the days of the Alamo, in this case, the Battle of Gonzales in 1835. In that battle, Mexican troops attempted to confiscate a cannon and the Texans raised a flag over it saying, “Come and take it”:
”UN poll watchers can’t interfere w/ Texas elections,” he tweeted. “I’ll bring criminal charges if needed. Official letter posted soon. #comeandtakeit ”
Can we get any more melodramatic than that? Well, they do say everything is bigger in Texas. That apparently includes bullshit.
It bears mentioning here that Texas’ voter ID law, which Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. called a “poll tax,” was blocked in federal court on August 30 of this year and that Abbott plans to appeal it to the Supreme Court. The Washington Post reported with regards to that event that,
the U.S. District Court in Washington ruled that Texas had failed to show that the statute would not harm the voting rights of minorities in the state. In addition, the judges found that evidence indicated that the cost of obtaining a photo ID to vote would fall most heavily on African American and Hispanic voters.
Evidence submitted by Texas to prove that its law did not discriminate was “unpersuasive, invalid, or both,” David S. Tatel, a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, wrote in the panel’s 56-page opinion. Voting Rights Act cases must be decided by a special panel of three federal judges.
It is hardly surprising then that Abbott should react so violently to the presence of those whose task it is to make sure that Texas is not going all cowboy on minority voters. Remember that the Texas law was blocked in federal court, and then look at what Abbott told ODIHR/OCSE:
“The OSCE may be entitled to its opinions about Voter ID laws, but your opinion is legally irrelevant in the United States, where the Supreme Court has already determined that Voter ID laws are constitutional.”
Apparently, Abbott feels no more constrained by facts than he does by the law.
Frantic as ever to keep the light from shining on Texas as it bullies the vote into line for Mitt Romney’s plutocratic theocracy, Texas Secretary of State Hope Andrade wrote to OSCE/ODIHR on Tuesday, saying,
“We have had a long and productive relationship with OSCE and election process observers,” The Texas Tribune reports Andrade as saying that the observation program “has provided valuable insights into the administrations of elections in various political systems and contexts. The exchange of information establishing best practices has been important and insightful and, up to now, completely devoid of any partisanship.”
So it is bipartisan to want a fair election process? There you have it, right out of the horse’s ass…er, mouth. At least Andrade had the cojones to admit it, if no other Republican will, though I’m sure that wasn’t her intention at all.
In support of his renegade attorney general and secretary of state, Governor Rick “Pray for Rain” Perry tweeted Tuesday,
”No UN monitors/inspectors will be part of any TX election process; I commend @TXsecofstate for swift action to clarify issue.”
Needless to say, the OCSE is not impressed by Texas bluster. In a press release Tuesday, the organization had this to say:
Ambassador Janez Lenarčič, the Director of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR), expressed his grave concern today over the threat of criminal prosecution of OSCE/ODIHR election observers.
This threat, contained in an open letter from the Attorney General of Texas, is at odds with the established good co-operation between OSCE/ODIHR observers and state authorities across the United States, including in Texas, Lenarčič said, adding that it is also contrary to the country’s obligations as an OSCE participating State.
The ODIHR Director shared his concerns in a letter to United States Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.
“The threat of criminal sanctions against OSCE/ODIHR observers is unacceptable,” Lenarčič said. “The United States, like all countries in the OSCE, has an obligation to invite ODIHR observers to observe its elections.”
The ODIHR Director also stressed that any concerns or reports that the election observers intended to influence or interfere with the election process were groundless. He underlined that OSCE/ODIHR election observers adhere to all national laws and regulations, as well as a strict code of conduct.
“Our observers are required to remain strictly impartial and not to intervene in the voting process in any way,” Lenarčič said. “They are in the United States to observe these elections, not to interfere in them.”
The ODIHR limited election observation mission for the 2012 general elections in the United States consists of a core team of 13 experts, from 10 OSCE participating States, based in Washington D.C., and 44 long-term observers deployed throughout the country. These are the sixth United States elections the Office has observed, without incident, since 2002.
Only Red State would think it makes sense to say, as they do, that because the OCSE has no binding authority over anyone they should not be allowed in polling places. If they can’t affect the outcome of the election, as even Red State admits, then what harm in letting them observe? Got something to hide, guys? Of course, Red State also thinks Richard Mourdock is the victim of a left-wing media witch hunt, if that helps put things in perspective.
Let’s face it: rationality is not a conservative strong suit this election cycle or at any time in the past decade.
On that subject, it is funny from the outside looking in that Texas conservatives love to appeal to the Alamo at every opportunity. They have completely lost sight of the fact that they have nothing in common with the defenders of the Alamo, who fought to free themselves from tyranny, but with General Antonio López de Santa Anna, who sought to impose it.
They forget, when they try to suppress the Latino vote, that among the defenders of the Alamo were about a dozen Tejanos, as they were called. In fact, the Tejano contingent boasted the only six defenders actually born in Texas: Juan Abamillo, Juan A. Badillo, Carlos Espalier, Gregorio Esparza, Antonio Fuentes, and Andrés Nava.
Rick Perry’s regime in Texas isn’t defending the Alamo, it’s attacking it.
Remember the Alamo indeed.
Things are never dull in the State of Texas. The reaction of State Officials to the idea of international ...
Rick Perry thinks that he speaks for everyone in the state of Texas, because the governor declared to report ...
Texas Attorney General, Greg Abbott threatened to arrest U.N. observers should they dare to observe in Texas ...
Republicans hate the United Nations. They hate globalism and the world government that supposedly threatens ...
Human beings are programmed with a need to control their environment whether it is in their place of abo ...
clarence swinney
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 8:10 am
off subject pardon so important for middle class
FREE TRADE=DISASTER
Our balance of trade is bad and
has little chance of being reversed.
This “Free” Trade ideology has allowed access to our economy for goods made overseas
under low wage structures plus government subsidized businesses and oftentimes dumping below cost to capture our markets. We have lost the bulk of many industries as textiles and apparel.
The “Free” trade has eliminated millions of our good, middle class jobs giving us a service/financial economy. This economy cannot support the “lifestyle” Americans have enjoyed for many decades. The top 1% has done well. Average income for them=1970-$318,000—1980–$318.000–1990–$393,000—2000—$875,000—2008—-$988,000—2010—$905,557
Share of wealth by 1%=20% in 1976 and 34% in 2004
We need tariffs plus enforcement of agreements to punish “dumping”.In the last decade we closed 58,000 plants. You can observe them in almost every city in North Carolina.
buckeyewill
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 8:33 am
Back on the subject:
These Tea Party extremists have BROUGHT it upon themselves by acting like a bunch of Fascist thugs trying to suppress the right to vote. When you act like reactionary Taliban thugs what did you expect??? Of course the NAACP and the ACLU will make it a Human Rights issue.
These issues were SETTLED LAST CENTURY. Why drag them upfront and in the spotlight??? Congress passed the Voting Rights Act, the Supreme Court laid down “One man,one vote” ruling, Section 5 Provision of the Act is still law, THEY WANT TO CONTINUE TO FIGHT AGAINST THE RIGHT TO VOTE.
The Tea Party is to blame for this foolishness.
Sandra
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 11:30 am
I wouldn’t blame just the Tbaggers, the entire Republican Party is involved with voter suppressions/registration fraud going back to 2000/4. I’m glad organizations had the sense to request the presence of these folks to monitor the elections. The eegits in Texas and other Red States should hang their heads in shame for what they have done to the country they profess to love. The rest of the world is cheering on the OSCE/ODIHR. This ought to be a wake up call to these unpatriotic R’thugs that the world is watching and judging.
Shiva (Moderator)
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 9:07 am
I do think we can detect some elements of paranoia here. A system of voting that is on the up and up would be open and transparent. The United States monitors elections in many countries under agreement and our being monitored is no different.
Whether this country was founded on religious principles, or the number of people who died at the Alamo for this country, is not relevant to this situation. This is about voting in the year 2012. I do think that we have heard so many times in the past from people who cannot think make this statement “if you have nothing to hide then you should not be worried about anything”
As far as I’m concerned anyone who tries to repress anyone from voting, needs to be in a federal penitentiary. Anyone who supports the vote being repressed a restricted is what I would call an AINO. An American in name only.
Texas has lived on a reputation for far too long. Most of its people live in our century. The leadership of Texas does not
Goddess1871
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 9:57 am
Honestly? Texas wants to be independent so effing bad, cut those aye-wholes loose.
Gary Vaughn
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 10:08 am
I don’t want them in Texas either. Their job would be better served to double down in Ohio, New Hampshire, Colorado, Michigan, North Carolina, Florida and Iowa.
RMuse
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 10:44 am
Texas has this issue that they are their own country and that is a problem, but they also believe their “country” gets to dictate policies and agendas for the entire nation. They want their independence, but they also want the Federal government’s money, protection, and laws that suit them. If Republicans weren’t cheating voters, the United Nations would not be required, so they’ve brought this on themselves. These are the same cretins who claim there is a U.N. secret mission to take over America and this plays into their little conspiracy theory. It is a sad commentary.
Johnee
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 11:12 am
Good analysis. A lot of us have had it with this “Texas seceding from the nation”. garbage.
Bill The Yaesuman
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 10:57 am
If this right wing facist bafoon attempts blocking international monitors from entering the polls in a Fedearl Election then Federal Marshalls should arrest him and anyone trying to prevent the monitors from doing what is legal under treaty.
SinghX
Oct. 26th, 2012 at 8:49 am
I would agree that arrest would get the ball rolling in the right direction for the entire country in terms of election interference; it would be a warning shot to the wanna-bees.
However, what kind of warning shot? Would it create the “Butterfly Effect” and start another Waco type shoot-out down in Texas via reactionary militants? An international incident? Create more conspiracies, fan the flames…?
Eric Holder would have a tough call…I don’t think it would not be the same as arresting that little a-hole from New Orleans who set up ACORN or broke into a Senator’s office (luckily can’t remember his name).
Johnee
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 11:01 am
Lately,there has been a lot of press regarding the fundie/conservative antics of Texas. I live in Austin and I can tell you that Hraf is absolutely correct. Officials do not want any kind of transparency that may expose any shady voter suppression tactics.
However I can also tell you that there is also a wind of change blowing through Texas, and it scares the crap out of the current leadership.
I live in the very progressive city of Austin, and
both Dallas and Houston have large pockets of progressiveness, if you will. Dallas has a large LGBT community (so does Houston), and the downtown area of Houston is dedicated to the arts and sciences; not to mention the ever growing Latino population throughout Texas as a whole.
Joseph Bristol
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 11:01 am
This guy is another POS Republican in a position of authority, that will try to stop anyone that might prevent them from cheating. these idiots will go to any length to insure a win for Romney. The sad part about it is that the main stream media, like CNN for example is not covering this.
robyn ryan
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 11:57 am
But- but- Jaysus is comin’ soon, and he Luvs us’n here in Texass! We’ve bin forgiven already!
Amy Simeister
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 12:31 pm
Simple as this, ANY state that refuses to comply and allow the UN vote observers and monitors should have their votes 100% not count.
Hemerson
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 12:57 pm
Actually, many historians have said that Texas seceded in part to protect slave owners in Texas, since Mexico had outlawed the practice. So, in that sense, today’s Texans have quite a lot in common with their Alamo heros.
Hrafnkell Haraldsson
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 2:36 pm
The only problem with that theory is that though Mexico had indeed banned slavery, it had, in the words of Jim Donovan (Blood of Heroes, 2012) “it’s own ‘peculiar institution’- its peonage system – in which dirt-poor peasants toiled on huge haciendas with little chance of earning freedom. They were burdened with massive debt, and, like southern slaves, endured hopeless conditions such as corporal punishment and severe penalties for escape. The sale of these human beings resembled slavery to a discomforting degree.”
Besides, as Donovan points out, the Texians simply ignored Mexico’s anti-slavery laws.
In other words, the Texians of 1836 did not have to secede from Mexico to protect slave-owning.
R Brown
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 4:30 pm
Sorry ya’ll feel the way you do .. but frankly we don’t really care … if someone can’t figure out that it costs nothing for a voter regsitration card they probably don’t know it is election day anyway ..and I just voted yesterday and was told I could provide my voter registration card or my driver’s license whichever I preferred .. not a very difficult thing to do ..you call it suppression..we call it protecting the integrity of the election process… Funny how asking for a simple ID is suppression but black panthers standing outside a polling place with weapons is not considered suppression by the President or his Attorney General. I have a lot more trust in the Attorney General of Texas than I do in Eric Holder Barrack Obama…and I am pretty sure we already have a process to protect voter rights ..our Constitution and our justice system.. we don;t need anyone from a corrupt UN getting involved. And by the way, us “dummies” have faired pretty well through the economic mess 6 years of Democratic control in Congress has gotten us into .. unlike NY , California and most other blue states …. we’re doing just fine down here while the rest of you are going broke paying your unions everything they want.
Shiva (Moderator)
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 4:36 pm
Unfortunatly you know very little about your state.
And even less about the congress. The Dems have been in charge of the Senate while the rape minded republicans have had the House.
And of course you didnt know that this is not new, the US monitors elections across the globe by agreement, as well as other countrys coming here.
Your state has one of the lowest graduation rates in the country. One of the most polluted. The most uneducated people. There is a huge list of things texas is last or almost last in.
And you show why
But I give you credit, you have memorized all the cliches you were given to quote
BTW, even Bush wouldnt convict or arrest the 3 black panthers. And suppression my totally uneducated friend occurs when minorities are targeted. You seem to know absolutely nothing about the situation
Luke
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 8:25 pm
While we are at it, why not just turn this country over to the UN? They can tax the hell out of it and give the money to Africa. They sounds like a great idea to me.
Shiva (Moderator)
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 8:33 pm
Hilarious! You do know our elections have been monitored since 2002?
“The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), a group that has observed U.S. elections since 2002, is sending dozens of monitors from around the world to monitor the presidential and congressional elections in the United States this November”
Its not the UN, even though Fox Snooze tells you it is. We also take part in monitoring other elections around the world.
Use google from now on if Fox lets you
Magdalena
Oct. 25th, 2012 at 10:37 pm
I grew up in McAllen, Texas and after high school graduation I moved to Wisconsin and lived there for almost 10 years. One thing that I learned from living in both states was that in Wisconsin, racism was hidden until they got to know you. The people in Wisconsin at least gave new comers a chance to show them who you were. In Texas racism is out in the open. White people in the 1970′s spoke to their racism against other people different than themselves daily. I lived through this racism growing up and had culture shock when I moved to Wisconsin. Texas in general has always been racist and discriminatory. Today’s issue on Voter Suppression by the Republicans is nothing new. That’s how elections are won by cheating. If they actually just let people vote their choice it would be a landslide re-election for President Obama. This Red state is slowly turning blue Thank God and all us progressives. So watch out You People Republicans, we’re coming after you.
river0
Oct. 26th, 2012 at 1:38 am
@Haraldsson
“These Red States sometimes forget we are a nation, a union of states under a single federal government and that individual states do not make foreign policy decisions, sign treaties, or decide which obligations to adhere to. You might be able to ignore biblical injunctions at will but states can’t ignore international treaties.”
Abbott might want to take a look at Article 6 of U.S. Constitution next time he’s bored with his Chamber of Commerce brochures:
“This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.”
The Texas executive branch seems to have forgotten the the “laws of Texas” do not apply to treaties entered into by the federal government. The Constitution expressly prohibits it. And until Texas once again commits treasonous, armed rebellion against the United States, it will always falls under the Constitution and laws of the United States. This fact should be made crystal clear to those sworn to know better. If by October 27, Abbott still insists on pursing his dangerous course, the United States Secretary of State should petition the federal courts for an enforcement order. And with such a federal court order in its hands, Abbott and Perry may see the 101st Airborne again enforcing federal law at tip of bayonet. Either that or find themselves facing a federalized “Texas” national guard tasked with enforcing a federal court order. It’s way past time to mess with Texas.