If you haven’t seen the interview, it was painful to watch. Lauren Green embarrassed herself and her network by attacking a scholar for writing a book in his area of expertise. It might be the worst Fox News interview ever (and there have been some bad ones).
What Green could not get over was that Aslan is a Muslim. That fact mattered far more to her than a PhD and four degrees (including one in the New Testament) and a fluency in New Testament Greek. What she demanded to know was, where does a Muslim get off writing a book about Jesus?
What Aslan wanted – and tried to make her understand – is that he is a religious scholar. He tried to point out to her that his conclusions about Jesus contradict not only Christian belief but also Muslim belief about Jesus. None of that mattered.
Watch and cringe:
From the moment these words leave Green’s lips, “You’re a Muslim. So why did you write a book about the founder of Christianity?” the interview is all downhill.
Green was being ridiculous. Fox News abounds with Christians who are so-called experts on Islam. No Fox interviewer to my knowledge has ever condemned any of them for being Christians writing about Islam.
From the outset, Green refused to accept Aslan’s findings because they disagreed with her beliefs. She attempted to refute him by citing people who disagree with him, revealing – among many other things – that she knows very little about how academia works.
As Aslan told her, “Of course, in any scholarly discussion of Jesus, as with any scholarly discussion of any ancient figure, there are going to be widespread differences.”
Of course, Aslan revealed he does not understand how conservative minds work when he bothered to mention his 100 pages of footnotes listing his sources as well as every scholar who agrees and disagrees with him. Facts are so…20th century.
In the end, her argument came down to this: that if Christian theologians disagreed with Aslan, then Aslan must be wrong. Belief trumps fact each and every time, after all. She could not wrap her head around the fact that this is a case of the Jesus of belief versus the Jesus of history.
Christianity is not a religion founded by Jesus, but a religion about Jesus, as Bart Ehrman has pointed out:
[I]f Jesus was the apocalyptic prophet that he appears to have been, then the Christianity that emerged after his death represents a somewhat different religion from the one he himself proclaimed. In the simplest terms, Christianity is a religion rooted in a belief in the death of Jesus for sin and his resurrection from the dead. This, however, does not appear to have been the religion that Jesus preached to the Jews of Galilee and Judea. To use a formulation that scholars have tossed about for years, Christianity is not so much the religion of Jesus (the religion that he himself proclaimed) as the religion about Jesus (the religion that is based on his death and resurrection).
Sadly, nobody briefed Hill on the background of the search for a historical Jesus or perhaps she thought her faith would shield her from facts, but the fact is, people have long debated who the historical Jesus was as compared to the figure promoted by the Christology that arose after his execution by the Romans.
For argument’s sake, let’s take a quick look at some of the various ways Jesus has been interpreted by scholars in this century alone :
The point here being that there are many possible historical Jesus’ in addition to the Jesus of belief (and even all those don’t agree!). Some might say that any of those listed above are more likely than the one subscribed to by Lauren Green based on the observed and endlessly repeated evidence that dead people stay dead.
The interview has created a bit of a firestorm on the twittersphere and CNN’s Leone Lakhani looked at some of them, pro and con.
CNN’s Piers Morgan later interviewed Aslan about his Fox News interview and Aslan allowed that he felt embarrassed by having to trot out his academic credentials throughout the interview.
He also told Morgan, “I completely understand where Lauren Green is coming from. I kind of feel bad for her. I mean, the truth of the matter is that when you write about religion like I do, you’re writing about something people take very seriously, and I understand that a lot of people, whether its Muslims or Christians or Jews or what have you, feel sometimes that academics like myself are attacking their faith, attacking their very identity.”
It was clear from the interview that like many conservative Christians, she is afraid of the historical Jesus. But Aslan told Morgan that his is not a book even about Christianity, let alone an attack on it. As he pointed out, Jesus was not a Christian, but a Jew, making it a book about Judaism.
Lauren Green in her interview tried to expose Reza Aslan’s supposed biases but in the end, she revealed only her own. And certain against all her hopes and expectations, she managed to make Aslan’s book a best seller. The New York Times observes, “On Friday, “Zealot” was in the No. 8 spot on Amazon.com, the nation’s biggest seller of books; by Sunday, it had hit No. 1.”
As Aslan said, “I’ll be perfectly honest — I’m thrilled at the response that people have had to the interview. You can’t buy this kind of publicity.”
That some Christians like Green don’t like the idea of a historical Jesus should hardly come as a surprise. Those same Christians don’t even like the Jesus of the New Testament. They just like having his name to conveniently attach to their own preconceived notions and bigotries.
My own footnotes to be ignored by those who find facts uncongenial:
Hrafnkell Haraldsson, a social liberal with leanings toward centrist politics has degrees in history and philosophy. His interests include, besides history and philosophy, human rights issues, freedom of choice, religion, and the precarious dichotomy of freedom of speech and intolerance. He brings a slightly different perspective to his writing, being that he is neither a follower of an Abrahamic faith nor an atheist but a polytheist, a modern-day Heathen who follows the customs and traditions of his Norse ancestors. He maintains his own blog, A Heathen’s Day, which deals with Heathen and Pagan matters, and Mos Maiorum Foundation www.mosmaiorum.org, dedicated to ethnic religion. He has also contributed to NewsJunkiePost, GodsOwnParty and Pagan+Politics.
President Biden explained his vision for America, got in a shot at Trump, and firmly…
You know things are getting serious for Trump when Rep. Jim Jordan wades in and…
Donald Trump and Ron DeSantis are in a slap fight over which networks get to…
Donald Trump did not take the news well that his former vice president is not…
Republicans have had nothing to say after May's bigger-than-expected jobs report revealed that President Biden…
Lawyers for Donald Trump say that they can't find the Iran document that Trump talked…