Republicans Join With Democrats In A Rare Bipartisan Senate Effort To Ban Torture

There is an idiom popularized about a century-and-a-half ago that says “all’s fair in love and war.” The phrase was a loose iteration taken from Miguel de Cervantes’ comparison in 1604 in Don Quixote where he wrote; “Love and war are all one…it is lawful to use sleights and stratagems to attain the wished end.” However, in war, like in love, there are some ‘stratagems and sleights‘ that are not lawful under any circumstances. For example, in matters of love, rape and violence are certainly not lawful any more than torturing prisoners duringwar is lawful in any conflict. There have been several international conventions and treaties in effect for decades, all of which America ratified and is a signatory to, that ban the use of torture. But this country, in particular, continued the banned practice as if it was a legal requirement to conduct a war when a Republican is president.

During the George W. Bush administration torture was not only condoned, it was encouraged by the administration and “deemed legal” because under a Republican administration America was so extraordinarily exceptional that Bush’s neo-con cabal concluded that no matter what international laws they violated, they were not going to be bound to follow any treaty, convention, or American military code. What was exceptional then, and continues to confound sane Americans, is that despite admitting, boasting about, and pledging to continue torturing prisoners right up to present day, Bush officials and those who tortured prisoners are still free and will never face prosecution for war crimes.

The American military has had bans against the use of torture under any circumstances since the nation’s inception, and still, on taking office in 2009, then new President Obama felt the need to issue an executive order on interrogation banning the use of torture. Now, six years later, the United States Senate felt the pressing need to overwhelmingly pass legislation banning the use of torture and it is a sign that even some Republicans are aware of a mindset among several Republicans running for the presidency that adhering to the idea that “all’s fair in war” allows torture and the only way to prevent a future, dog-forbid, Republican administration from not only condoning, but ordering the use of torture with immunity from prosecution, is passing another law banning the practice.

The vote in the Republican-controlled Senate on Monday was an overwhelming bipartisan statement that the President’s 2009 executive order banning torture must be ensconced in permanent law to prevent a Republican administration’s repeat performance in the future. The vote was 78 – 21 in the form of an amendment added to the fiscal 2016 National Defense Reauthorization Act and it forbid the use of torture by “any agent of the U.S. government,” as well as “standardized certain ‘non-coercive interrogation methods across the military and intelligence sector.” Leading the charge to again “officially” ban the use of torture was Viet Nam Veteran and torture survivor Republican John McCain and Vice Chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee Democrat Dianne Feinstein. The “no torture” amendment was a continuation project for Senator Feinstein who was a fierce crusader for the release of an exposé on the dysfunctional and abusive torture practices by the CIA that were approved and encouraged by the Bush administration.

In reality, it is as absurd that the United States Congress has to pass a law banning torture as it was ridiculous and embarrassing for America that an incoming Democratic President had to issue an executive order banning the practice George Washington said “brought shame, disgrace and ruin” to American soldiers and their country. Disgraceful and illegal as it is, torturing prisoners was a practice the Bush administration boasted about. Following closely the President’s 2009 executive order, the new legislation restricts all U.S. personnel to using only approved interrogation techniques found in the Army Field Manual.

According to constitutional law professor David Cole, the new Senate legislation appears to be a safeguard specifically designed to prevent any future Republican warmongering administration from deliberately re-interpreting existing laws to “permit what they were plainly designed to prohibit.” It was precisely the ploy that George W. Bush used when he ordered his Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel to;create torture ‘memos’ legalizing decades-old “banned interrogation techniques” that any thinking human being considers torture. Professor Cole explained that the new legislation banning torture wisely approaches the issue differently than previous bans and noted that, “Instead of expressing a broad prohibition, it confines interrogators to a set list of expressly approved techniques. That approach, already used by the military for their interrogations, avoids ambiguity; if a technique is not affirmatively approved, it is banned.”

However, those techniques that are not, and were never ever, “approved” by America’s military were routinely put into practice on the advice and consent of the Bush administration; likely because they thought they were above American and international law. The fact that they were not placed under arrest, prosecuted, and summarily executed by firing squad, and are free to continue boasting about their war crimes means that Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld et al were and are above the law.

The Bush administration’s many war crimes, including approving the use of torture on captive combatants and innocent Muslims alike was, and still is, a major cause of shame, disgrace, and ruination for America’s reputation abroad although many Americans still think it is a mark of heroic exceptionalism. Despite his executive order banning the use of torture, it really appeared that the current administration wanted to pretend it never happened by “looking forward as opposed to looking backwards.” Perhaps if the Senate’s anti-torture amendment ever reaches the President’s desk it will jog his memory and remind him that his failure to prosecute the Bush administration war criminals is tantamount to, at the very least, tacit approval of the banned practices.

The idea of torturing prisoners was so abhorrent to one of America’s most revered Founders, and the one man regarded as the Father of our country, George Washington, that he issued orders to his commanders warning of the harshest consequences to any American soldier found causing harm to a prisoner of war. In a charge to the Northern Expeditionary Force, Washington said “Should any American soldier be so base and infamous as to injure any prisoner, I do most earnestly enjoin you to bring him to such severe and exemplary punishment as the enormity of the crime may require. Should it extend to death itself, it will not be disproportional to its guilt at such a time and in such a cause. For by such conduct they bring shame, disgrace and ruin to themselves and their country.” On Monday, the United States Senate took a giant bipartisan step toward making certain that no American will ever again bring shame, disgrace, and ruin to this country again; at least until, dog forbid, Americans elect another Republican as president.

View Comments

  • It says a great deal to me that the so-called "Party of Personal Responsibility" did everything it could to flout the laws of the United States, and the Geneva Conventions- all so they could feel good for the basest and most vile things they did.

    Unfortunately- an Executive Order of today, can be overturned with another Executive Order of tomorrow.

    But even a Constitutional Amendment- does not stop those determined to break the Law.

    "Stop Throwing the Constitution in my face! It's just a goddamned piece of paper!"

    Allegedly uttered by a President previous to Obama.

  • It is a great time to bring up this issue, and even if it does not get resolved.

    This torture issue will bring to light & remind the nation what a creep the BUSH president was.

    Hey people!
    JEB BUSH is cut from the same material of the guy who brought you the Patriot Act, abuse of power & the intrussion into personal liberties.

  • This is good but, it should have been 99 or 100 to 0, (Rubio did not vote; wonder why).

    Here are the 21 losers who voted nay:

    Barrasso - R-WY
    Blunt - R-MO
    Coats - R-IN
    Cochran - R-MS
    Coryn - R-TX
    Cotton (surprised, not!) - R-AR
    Crapo - R-ID
    Ernst - R-IA
    Fischer - R-NE
    Ms. Graham - R-SC
    Hatch - R-UT
    Inhofe - R-OK
    Lankford - R-OK
    Lee - R-UT
    McConnell the Turtle - R-KY
    Risch - R-ND
    Roberts - R-KS
    Sasse - R-NE
    Scott - R-SC
    Sessions - R-AL
    Vitter - R-LA

      • Moongrim we also had many Nazi Germans and others killed for war crimes. Something Shrub and Cheney escaped. This new bill I hope, will begin to heal the terrible reputation our Nation now has. we have a long-long way to go to be a trusted Nation once again. All because of Bush, Cheney and those who followed them.

  • I wonder how many of us had relatives or family friends who were prisoners of war during WWII in Germany. I had an uncle, as well as a HS math teacher who was actually in the same camp depicted in The Great Escape. The penalty for trying to escape was, indeed, torture (via a bullet) but otherwise most of those thousands upon thousands of PoWs came home -- in one piece.

    How on earth the Bushites could sanction such horrific torture methods on fellow human beings, claiming American exceptionalism, is just mind-boggling. But perhaps they thought, if the Japanese could do it during WWII in the Pacific theatre, then that was A-OK.

    Sorry folks, the Bush gang gave "exceptionalism" a whole new meaning.....

  • I'm not surprised at all that all the no votes were Republicans. They have no empathy, no conscience and no soul. If one of their relatives were ever caught by Al Quida or ISIL and tortured though, that would be intollerable. If any one of our brave soldiers is ever tortured in the future, they need to look at themselves in the mirror and see the face to blame for it.

  • If any of you have a chance to, see the documentary Unknown Knowns about Donald Rumsfeld. You will see how the sociopathic mind works here. FFS.

  • ...I just hope that, should these bastards travel to Europe they will be IMMEDIATELY arrested...pity the World Court has NO death penalty...

Recent Posts

Trump Doesn’t Get What He Wants As Judge Could Release Partial Redacted Mar-a-Lago Search Affidavit

A federal judge said that he could release portions of a redacted affidavit for the…

13 mins ago

Trump’s Classified Docs Defense Backfires On Him

Trump pointed to a memo related to the declassification of some documents that undermines his…

2 hours ago

John Fetterman Lead Causes PA Senate Race To Be Moved To Lean Democrat

The Cook Political Report has moved the Pennsylvania US Senate contest from toss-up to lean…

3 hours ago

Trump Threatens Agents’ Lives By Wanting To Release Video of Search

Trump is threatening to release the video of the FBI's search, which would put the…

4 hours ago

Trevor Noah Busts Trump For Using A Ghostwriter For His Posts

The Daily Show's Trevor Noah pointed out why there is no way that Trump the…

16 hours ago

Biden Drops The Hammer On Republican Calls To Defund The FBI

President Biden told Republicans that the FBI won't be defunded and pushed for additional funding…

20 hours ago