Categories: Featured NewsIssues

State Department memo shows unconstitutionality of Trump travel ban: ACLU

By Yeganeh Torbati and Mica Rosenberg

WASHINGTON/NEW YORK (Reuters) – Internal State Department instructions to implement President Donald Trump’s temporary travel ban on citizens of six Muslim-majority nations help demonstrate that the ban violates the constitution, the American Civil Liberties Union argued in court filings.

The ACLU made the argument as part of its lawsuit in federal court in the Northern District of California on behalf of three student visa holders against Trump’s March 6 executive order barring travelers from Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen from entering the United States for 90 days and refugees for four months. The lawsuit, which seeks class-action status, says the order discriminates against Muslims.

U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson issued instructions to implement Trump’s order in a series of four cables to consular officers worldwide last month, which were first revealed by Reuters.

The ACLU pointed to language from one of the cables that directs consular officers to assess whether applicants from the six countries “found otherwise eligible” for U.S. visas could still be denied visas based on Trump’s order. The ACLU said the guidance “amounts to an unconstitutional amendment of existing law.”

Tillerson issued the cable on March 10, and followed it with another set of instructions on March 15, the day before the ban was supposed to go into effect. After federal courts blocked the central tenets of Trump’s order, Tillerson issued two other cables that rescinded many of his previous instructions but left some tighter visa vetting procedures in place.

A State Department official declined to comment on the litigation or the cables. The Department of Justice also declined to comment.

The Trump administration has said that the travel ban and increased screening of foreigners are crucial to protecting the United States from terrorist attacks. The government is arguing in court that the president has broad authority under the law to make immigration decisions when there are concerns about national security.

The March executive order replaced a more sweeping travel ban that Trump signed on Jan. 27, which sparked chaos and protests at airports and was challenged by more than two dozen lawsuits. The original ban had covered citizens of Iraq, as well as the six countries also included in the revised ban. Iraq was dropped from the revised order, as was an indefinite ban on all refugees from Syria.

The revised ban aimed to overcome legal hurdles by excluding legal permanent residents and allowing for waivers for people with ties to the United States. The ACLU, in its claims that the order discriminates against Muslims, points to calls by Trump on the campaign trail for a “Muslim ban” and to a speech he made last month calling the new ban a “watered-down” version of the first.

(Additional reporting by Dan Levine in San Francisco; Editing by Leslie Adler)

Reuters

Recent Posts

Kamala Harris Raised More Money In 3 Months Than Trump Has All Year

Kamala Harris has raised more money in three months than Donald Trump has during all…

4 hours ago

Trump Melts Down And Claims 60 Minutes Edited Kamala Harris Interview To Make Her Look Presidential

Trump showed that he knows how well the 60 Minutes interview went for Kamala Harris,…

6 hours ago

The Kremlin Knifes Trump And Confirms Secret Putin Covid Tests

Trump denied sending Putin Covid tests, but the Kremlin released a statement confirming that Trump…

10 hours ago

With Less Than A Month Before Election Day, Trump Is Losing Pennsylvania

A new poll shows Vice President Kamala Harris leading ex-president Donald Trump 50%-46 in the…

1 day ago

Trump Campaign Plants Fake Auto Workers At JD Vance Michigan Event

JD Vance held an event in Detroit that included people wearing Autoworkers For Trump t-shirts…

1 day ago

Trump Has Held As Many As 7 Private Illegal Conversations With Putin Since Leaving Office

Bob Woodward reports in his new book that Trump has held as many as seven…

1 day ago