552 Comments
User's avatar
Aimee Houghton's avatar

I get they are shaking up prime time. However. Canceling Joy Reid but not Morning Joe whose ratings have done nothing but decline? Only at MSNBC.

Sarah Jones & Jason Easley's avatar

Morning Joe is a cash cow and the second most powerful show on MSNBC. Scarborough will NEVER be canceled, because corporate media is all about money.---Jason

Tom Huff's avatar

He’s cancelled in our house. He is nothing but a bloviating buffoon.

HoldingTheLine(HTL)'s avatar

EVERY sentence uttered starts with an "I" of some iteration. Yawn.

Elizabeth's avatar

I wrote them off when I read they had gone to trump. Before they ever opened their collective mouths. Truthfully, I haven't missed it either.

Deborah C's avatar

Bye, Joe Blow Scarborough 👋 Don’t need the Trump ass kissers.

Evelyn Freitas's avatar

Right, so fire the women of color and let’s hear it for the white guy!

Barbara Morgan's avatar

The only two I like to watch is Nicole Wallace and Joy Reid 🤨✌🏻💙

Ann Corbeau's avatar

Joy is being replaced by Symone Sanders, Michael Steele, and Alicia Menendez. So 2 blacks and a Latina. So no, that's not it.

Evelyn Freitas's avatar

I’m glad to hear that, and by “the white guy”, I mean Joe Scarborough, whom I’ve been told “is never going anywhere”, by the very experienced industry people who are very kindly explaining things to us on this comment thread.

Matthew Witters's avatar

Always someone gonna play the race card...

Susan Fujimoto's avatar

think a little more deeply on it. She is the only Black person who communicated strongly and clearly against the new administration's obscenities.

Matthew Witters's avatar

Again, what the hell does her being black have to do with anything?

Stephen's avatar

It may mean a lot to a big chunk of her audience. I think she spoke for and to African-American issues in only the way another African-American could. Don't be obtuse thinking you're being fair.

Beth L. Wolcott's avatar

That's to bad, lost all respect for them both after running to marlargo to kiss the ring!! Disgusting!!!

Karen's avatar

And because Joe is an alpha WHITE man. So. All the boys stick together. It is lamely pathetic and disgusting that msnbc etc can’t think creatively with and for women who are the backbone.

Bridget Collins's avatar

He was a cash cow.

What are his actual ratings these days?

Matthew Witters's avatar

You mean THE media... don't normalize calling media out like it's untrustworthy. We have media and propaganda. Truth is truth, lies are lies.

Don't Stop Me Now - TLawrence's avatar

I forgot about Morning Joe. I stopped watching news altogether for weeks after they went to Trump's "castle".

Patti Williams's avatar

So did I. I never liked him. Misogynistic bully.

Holly Polich's avatar

I stopped watching in 2015 when they normalized a Trump candidacy. They had him on practically every week for light-hearthed conversation. It was insane.

esperanza ramos's avatar

Seriously. She is one of the few people I would watch. Forget that sticking to independent media and places like Substack and Bluesky

Punkette's avatar

Joy should start her own Substack so we can continue to support her!

Helen Dael's avatar

Yes!! She should come to Substack. She will be appreciated here.

Punkette's avatar

Yes, Helen! Like Jim Acosta, Joy would finally be free to speak her mind and interview whomever she wants, with no more corporate media breathing down her neck and telling her (via earpiece) to tone it down. C’mon over to Substack, Joy-Ann! We want you! 💙

Pat's avatar

I agree Joy should do this id rather be gone,

Punkette's avatar

Yes! I subscribed! Here is her Substack, called Joy’s House: https://joyannreid.substack.com/

Maggie's avatar

Joy Ann Reid would never have pulled this bullshit ….

“Kristen Welker placing the responsibility on Democrats to work with Donald Trump and get things done.” Sarah Jones& Jason Easley on Sunday

The republican brown coat nazis has a small control of both houses, yet Welker suggested that the responsibility to work with hitler2 to get things done, was on Democrats! Bullshit! Mainstream media folks! Cory Booker squelched it with one swift kick! Very dumb move of msnbc to remove Joy!

Debi Jones's avatar

I liked Chris Matthews and thought they did him dirty. I can’t stand Joe Scarborough! He’s a smart ass.

Tom Huff's avatar

Matthews was a misogynist who very rudely cut off or talked over his women guests. That’s why he was canned. He probably sprayed on his guests too when he went on his foaming-at-the-mouth rants about the same thing for the hundredth time..

Fortunately, they canned him right before I went at my TV with an ax.

Punkette's avatar

Agree, Tom. I never liked Chris Matthews and was annoyed when MSNBC brought him back last fall as some sort of knowledgeable talking head. He turns my stomach.

Debi Jones's avatar

So what does Joe Scarborough do? He’s a lot ruder than Chris!

Tom Huff's avatar

I can hold them both as contemptuous sewer rats simultaneously.

Stephen's avatar

I think Joe speaks to and for the aging frat boys watching the news at the gym in the morning.

CA Productions/Carol Ann's avatar

I loved Chris. Is he on Stubstack

Citizen Satirist (CS)'s avatar

They are Deep State operatives...:

MEDIAsteria: Best Morning Joe & Mika Memes

Bend the knee & kiss the ring b*tches, remembering the Trump-Mika lovefest, some people are a big MAD and more Morning Joe & Mika memes as they try to make peace with the Donald!

https://covidsteria.substack.com/p/mediasteria-best-morning-joe-and-mika-memes?utm_source=publication-search

User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 24, 2025
Comment removed
Peggy Lucas's avatar

Democrats tend to eat their own!

Tom Huff's avatar

I don’t think a blatant misogynist falls under the category of “our own”. At least for most non-MAGAts. But you’re free to like them.

Oh,  it’s you's avatar

Knee jerk reaction by msnbc, they blew it when they fired Mehdi Hasan

Don't Stop Me Now - TLawrence's avatar

...and moved Ali Velchi to weekends. They both offered a different slant than just your basic white Christian. Joe Scarborough likes to hear himself talk, and he talks over everyone else, including his wife. They can keep Morning Joe but replace HIM.

Bruce Jordan's avatar

Joe Scarborough has moved from someone with an over-inflated, bloated ego to someone (IMO) that's crept into the early stages of narcissism. As bad as Donald Trump? Of course not. Trump has a disease: malignant narcissism. Scarborough has simply never embraced the idea of self reflection. I learned a long time ago (I'm 78 years old) that there are 3 magic words that will almost always make most people better human beings if they learn to incorporate them into their lives : "I was wrong".

Don't Stop Me Now - TLawrence's avatar

Bruce, you are right on all counts. My favorite saying is: “If you have the choice between being right or being kind, choose kind.” Scarborough thinks he’s always right, and by talking over his guests and co-hosts he shows lack of respect. Not a good trait for a host.

TCinLA's avatar

Yes to that, and the other thing that will finally civilize the average white American male (speaking from experience) is to learn and live the concept of "give to get."

Bernadette McCool's avatar

Abso freaking loooootly!!

Deborah C's avatar

Ali Velshi deserves better than he’s getting.

Matthew Witters's avatar

you assume that the white newscasters on msnbc are christian? This is the kind of stuff that caused so many center whites to vote for trump.

Publia's avatar

I don't know about any of the others, but both Joe and Lawrence have stated they are Christians, or have a Christian background, although not of the toxic variety that MAGATs express.

CA Productions/Carol Ann's avatar

He has diarrhea of the mouth. I stopped watching after his ass-kissing session at Mar-a-Shit-hole.

Sheila's avatar

Absolutely. MSNBC showed their obsession with ratings and neglect of the truth when they dropped Mehdi. Cowards.

Patricia Myers's avatar

I really liked Mehdi! Never will watch Joe again after they kissed the ring. And Joy Reid is full of herself and going bald didn’t help her any. I love Ali Velshi. I still watch MSNBC but they are on the fence so hopefully they can get their act together.

DeePR's avatar

That’s a rude comment about Joy Reid’s haircut! Maybe you didn’t like her style but many of us enjoyed her honesty and straight forward reporting.

Patricia Myers's avatar

Joy Reid didn’t have a hair cut! She shaved her head and was bald. Very ugly IMO.

DeePR's avatar

You know what they say about opinions! Going after a woman’s physical appearance is very “Right” of you! You don’t know if she did it for fashion or if she has alopecia, etc. I’m sure not everyone likes your personal style either.

Layla Osman Graham's avatar

Aw, you’re cute.

Post a photo of yourself!

Can’t wait to see how drop dead gorgeous you are.

ALI IS BALD

Beth's avatar

Personally, I couldn't stand Mehdi. I always turned it off when he was on. But we're all allowed choices.

mike bianculli's avatar

Why was Mehdi an issue for you?

Beth's avatar

If I'm remembering correctly, he was ALWAYS pretty snotty about Hillary Clinton. Not fond of Obama, not of Biden. He was pure Bernie-bro. Plus, he just irritates me. I don't disagree with him a lot, but getting on Hillary for garbage reasons lost me.

Pam Rhodes's avatar

Mehdi was a shining light. I still follow him here on Substack. The only two left on MSNBC are Nicole Wallace and Lawrence O’Donnell. Both I believe are doing the best they are able in this horrible time.

I haven’t watched cable since the election but; I hate to see Joy fired. She is joyful and we so need that.

B Lynn Adcock's avatar

Yep! Mehdi was speaking truth about Israel, Hamas and Palestinians.

Jacqdupmusic's avatar

I really appreciated Joy. She presented information with genuine attitude and sense of humor. MSNBC’s problem with losing viewership most recently was due to.Morning Joe kissing “the ring” of 47.

Xander H's avatar

That, and MSNBC never kept up with the slow demise of cable tv and many viewers' preference for a streaming model. Had they set up streaming plans for MSNBC content, I bet ratings would've been competitive with or better than any news show, even with the same lineup. Joy Reid is great, and I look forward to seeing the better place she lands.

FingerLakesGirl's avatar

I think MANBC would have done better to go streaming and actually compete with Faux News in the same way. By only being a paid “cable” type network, so many didn’t see it. This possibly could have changed the outcome if that sham of an election as well.

Publia's avatar

I don't have a TV and only see TV shows on YouTube or Netflix. I doubt my viewing counts for anything in the ratings, but I think there may be many others out there like me.

CA Productions/Carol Ann's avatar

I have no TV by choice for the last 12 or more years. I stream MSNBC and pick and choose what I watch. Nicolle Wallace is my must-see the rest of it, not so much.

Donna Cook's avatar

Agreed. Joe and Mica disgust me.

Ellen M George's avatar

Joy Reid and Alex Wagner speak truth to power. This is why they will be cut from the lineup. They are two very savvy and knowledgable women. This is a huge loss.

Bonnie's avatar

Agree. I was really pleased when Alex Wagner got a show here again. Have always liked her, and generally watch Joy Reid's show too. A lot of us backed away from watching politics after the horror election. Still hard to stomach. Need to let things get back on track for longer imo.

Nancy's avatar

Ditto. I like Joy and Alex. But I stopped watching both CNN and MSNBC completely before the election, and haven’t gone back. Not because I don’t “like” them or distrust their content, but because the news was just too traumatizing. Now I rely on Bluesky, YouTube, Straight Arrow News and Substack so I can better control when I watch and for how long to maintain some level of mental health.

Bonnie's avatar

Exactly. But I'm slowly engaging again, as much as I am able. Dark times.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 23, 2025
Comment removed
Nancy's avatar

Thanks, I did not know that. To be fair, what I like about it is the option to choose a story and check out left, right and center reports on same.

Susan Fujimoto's avatar

It is such a huge loss that I will not watch ANY MSNBC shows anymore. Joy spoke truth to power more than any other anchor on the station. She was the best! Alex was good, too. MSNBC keeps getting rid of their best journalists! Why bother to watch it anymore?

Ms Donna Martin's avatar

She’s a black woman…2 strikes against her in the corporate world’s eyes right there. I’m not surprised but I am offended and sickened by this move.

Aeneas's avatar

She didn't kiss the ring of white power like Welker. So she must go.

The Legal Edition's avatar

No one should be made to kiss any ring of any want to be dictator-ever!

DeuceFlash's avatar

Rashida Jones, also black, was replaced which is something I missed until reading this article about Joy and the rest. I suspect Joy losing her show is a direct result of Rashida being gone too.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 23, 2025
Comment deleted
DeuceFlash's avatar

Lawrence O’Donnell is the only one I can think of that hasn’t changed his tune and continues to tell the truth. He is the only one I will continue to watch. I hope he survives the bloodbath.

Beth's avatar

I like Michael Steele and would watch him with his own show. He's funny+ smart. Both needed in these times. Plus, he knows these Republican thugs.

DeuceFlash's avatar

The man you see now, is the Steel post being kicked to the curb by his beloved party. He was critical of President Obama and leading the Rs against him. Fast forward to the world today and well he has to find a way to make a buck. He is in the same class with Donald’s, Carson, Candace what’s her name, and all of the black people who have associated with this R party. Here’s an article from the Obama years where he called Obama a media creation. I respect your views on Steele but I don’t share them. https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2009/01/new-rnc-chair-michael-steeles-hypocrisy-barack-obama-video/

Beth's avatar

If I remember, and I do, the R's named him speaker after Obama won so they could pretend not to be racist. They dumped him pretty quickly, too. He's a decent man. More than can be said for most Rs now.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 24, 2025
Comment deleted
DeuceFlash's avatar

Exactly! It’s so nice to have a conversation, respectful of each others views and agree to disagree. 😊

Ms Donna Martin's avatar

He’s not afraid to speak truth to power. I love his show.

Beth's avatar

His ratings are the highest on the network, last I heard. I like him, too.

PJV's avatar

Me too. He and Rachel.

Barbara's avatar

I watch Rachel and Lawrence and occasionally Chris . I don't know think they should have gotten rid of Joy ! You are going to be losing a lot of viewers thinking it was a DEI fire nope definitely a wrong move manbc

JP's avatar

....well, Nicole, when I can take her voice. It's tough to understand someone who doesn't open their mouth in order to speak. But I like the show.

Maren's avatar

Same, the only 2 I watch!!

CA Productions/Carol Ann's avatar

Jen Psaki (she leaves the P off her pronunciation. I grew up with Polish neighbors who pronounced it correctly) is she of Japanese descent? I don't like her. I think Alicia Mendez is far more qualified to do in-depth interviews

Theresa Fuller's avatar

MSNBC needs to cancel Morning Joe to get me back. I was a faithful viewer of everything MSNBC until Joe and Mika decided to go to Mara-Lago to kiss Trump’s ass. I won’t be back until they are gone.

Bruce Jordan's avatar

PLEASE don't give up on MSNBC because of the foolish behavior of a man and a woman who know better. There are reports that MSNBC could vanish. That horrifies me! Don't penalize the rest of the lineup because of the cowardly behavior of only two people.

FingerLakesGirl's avatar

Me too. It’s like giving in, just what Trump, Musk, Project 25 and Republicans who only care about keeping power are hoping for. If people don’t pay attention and fight, our country will be gone as a democracy!

TCinLA's avatar

I've never watched them and didn't miss them, and I doubt most of the people here who "dislike them" were ever regular viewers of the show. It's another case of lefty self righteousness leading to being proud of cutting off one's nose to spite their face. From 50+ years on the left, it's a common lefty failing.

Evelyn Freitas's avatar

Who’s being self righteous?

Bridget Collins's avatar

Or why throw good money after bad?

I have never had cable so I watched Morning Joe, Nicole Wallace, Joy Reid and Michael Steele on YouTube.

Until the election.

At this point, I feel about MSNBC the way I feel about the WaPo.

I can't trust they'll give me the news without spinning it to please corporate owners. I can't trust they're not sitting on stories because it might make mango baby angry.

If I'm going to have to double check them, I might as well stick with the AP and Reuters.

Sarah Jones & Jason Easley's avatar

Again, folks, give it up. Morning Joe is never going anywhere.---Jason

Evelyn Freitas's avatar

Please stop telling people to “give it up”. I respect your opinion (that’s what it is), and I’d appreciate you allowing others to express theirs. Thank you.

TCinLA's avatar

If you appreciate people saying the truth, Jason is speaking from the experience of being a professional in the business.

Evelyn Freitas's avatar

Again, it’s an opinion which may or may not turn out to be true. Context is key in human communication, and in my opinion, it’s coming across as insistent and tone deaf mansplaining, whether that’s the intention or not. One can be right and allow others to express their feelings of loss, which are not about correctness.

Kate Madison's avatar

I am going to weigh in on this and agree with Jason. All media is about profits--money and greed. If they had a popular zebra, they would put him/her on the air. Corporate greed is the name of the game--more so now than ever! And after all, MSNBC is run by a corporation. End of story.

Maggie's avatar

Maybe yes, and maybe no! This household stopped watching mj & mika since he went to maralargo to suck on trunp! We will watch only Rachel and Lawrence from now on! Substack provides what we need to know about the pending hitler2republican dicktatorship.

Jodie's avatar

I still watch Nicole Wallace

Beth L. Wolcott's avatar

What is substack?? I'm on sky blue and AP, newsworthy, any others

The Legal Edition's avatar

Substack is a platform where authors and content producers like myself post articles, programs, interviews - where people can join and Subscribe. It runs the gamut of interests, you just need to find yours. TheLegalEdition.Substack.com

PJV's avatar

I recognize that, so I won’t be back.

The Legal Edition's avatar

They could just get another guy named Joe and the program would gain viewers. Just as Fort Bragg was named after another soldier named Bragg and no longer the Confederate general - finding another host named Joe would be preferable and just fine with viewers!

The Legal Edition's avatar

For more legal analysis and interviews, join me on Substack & Subscribe! TheLegalEdition.Substack.com

mike bianculli's avatar

I as well, MSNBC can go fuck itself until that happens

Martha Fiorillo's avatar

I will miss Joy Reid.She spoke the truth. Truth is being replaced with false facts

The Legal Edition's avatar

Joy was a treasure. She put power to words. Big mistake MSNBC!

The Legal Edition's avatar

If you like Joy Reid, come join me on Substack. TheLegalEdition.Substack.com

User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 23, 2025
Comment removed
Jemtl65's avatar

Dude, go somewhere with yourself. You're a hater. Im surprised you're not for Trump.

Shawn Hurst's avatar

I feel like y’all are caving to the new administration. I stopped watching Morning Joe bc of their capitulation. Joy always says what I’m thinking. So does Rachael. Whatever get decided, I feel like it should be directly opposite of what the orange assclown wants/says…

Nancy B's avatar

If you can’t replace MJ, then replace Katie Tur. She’s not on our side.

Shawn Hurst's avatar

She’s harmless compared to MJ

Deborah C's avatar

I’ll agree with that!!

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 23, 2025
Comment deleted
Debi Jones's avatar

I don’t care for her.

Joe St. Martin's avatar

I bet Joe would be a member of Mar-a-lago if he thought he could get away with it He reminds me of that Washington type "boys club" mentality.

Bruce Jordan's avatar

Joe Scarborough is nothing more than a good-old-boy, Southern Baptist Bible-thumper, hauling a huge over inflated, bloated ego and tinged with a touch of misogyny (look at the way he treats his wife). I posted earlier that I believe he's moved into the early stages of narcissism as well.

Shawn Hurst's avatar

I agree, wholeheartedly.

Beth L. Wolcott's avatar

I bet if let go he would go to fox fake news!!!!

The Legal Edition's avatar

MSNBC is certainly capitulating with these recent cancellations. All a bad move.

Joe St. Martin's avatar

I hope they didn't react based on the first couple of months after the election because a lot of us viewers were in stunned mode and couldn't watch anything until we gathered our bearings.

The Legal Edition's avatar

There is talk that MSNBC may go away or be bought out. This is not the time for their voices to be silenced by craziness and conspiracy theories. The voice of reason must go on. Hope you will check out my Substack and Subscribe! TheLegalEdition.Substack.com

Joe St. Martin's avatar

I think I did hear that NBC is spinning off MSNBC from NBC Universal/Comcast.

Lynne's avatar

I have grown to appreciate her. And will honestly miss her

K. Leonard's avatar

MSNBC should cut the Trump boot lickers on in the morning and put Joy in the morning slot. MSNBC will regret this decision.

Deb Della Piana's avatar

Americans don't want to hear about Donald Trump? That's part of the reason we're here. I suggest the American people grow up and face facts. You can't tune out a fascist pig and you can't ignore a coup. Americans, compared to the rest of the world, are TODDLERS playing in a sand box.

Bruce Jordan's avatar

Jesus Christ, people! "Americans don't want to hear about Donald Trump". Well, you had better get used to it. What do you folks suggest : burying our heads in the sand??? That bastard is going to be around for the next 4 years doing his best to destroy Our Country. I want to know every goddamned thing that son-of-a-bitch is doing! Ignorance is NOT bliss!

The Legal Edition's avatar

We don't need ostriches with heads in sand, we need lots of eagles, American Eagles - watchful and ready to take action! Come join me! TheLegalEdition.substack.com

Beth L. Wolcott's avatar

Already has a good start!!

The Legal Edition's avatar

And that sandbox is quickly becoming a litterbox with the new MAGA in chief!

The Legal Edition's avatar

Join me on Substack and Subscribe to learn more: TheLegalEdition.Substack.com

Robynne Limoges's avatar

Joy Reid is a huge loss. They are letting her go in another deferential kneeling to Trump. Because Joy did not suffer fools gladly, nor did she toe the pro-trump propaganda’s line.

J Gatton Prats's avatar

Joy Reid is a Patriot who speaks truth to power. We need her voice!

Shari Szilagyi's avatar

They should have cancelled morning turncoat sexist JOE. Joy is solid as is Alex. I think they are making grave errors

Sarah Jones & Jason Easley's avatar

That will never ever happen. That is like saying MSNBC will cancel Maddow, which will never happen.---Jason

Shari Szilagyi's avatar

It will if people quit watching like we did and send scathing letters stating why.

Shari Szilagyi's avatar

That is a hell of a weak ass thing to say. Sit down if you have no fight in you. We are about 80 million strong hon. We the people have the power if we exercise it.

LeAnn's avatar

I am going to miss both of these ladies…here on the west coast this is who I turn on as soon as I am home from work. Love and appreciate their in depth knowledge and perspective.