Another GOP Talking Point Dies as Report Reveals that Social Security Is Not Going Broke

Last updated on September 25th, 2023 at 01:36 pm

Republican claims that Social Security is going broke were dealt a blow by the latest Social Security trustees report, which found that the program will be able to pay every benefit until 2033.

The report echoed the same tone as last year. Social Security is fine for the next twenty years. The report also contained good news for Medicare, as it is now projected to be solvent until 2026. In a statement, Sen. Bernie Sanders stressed that these findings confirmed what the reality based political world already knew. Sen. Sanders said, “The report from the Social Security trustees confirms what many of us have known, that Social Security is not ‘going broke,’ that it can pay every benefit owed to every eligible American for the next 20 years and that after 2033 there is enough in reserve to pay three-quarters of future benefits.”

To get more stories like this, subscribe to our newsletter The Daily.

Republicans have been claiming that Social Security is going broke for years in order to justify the privatization of the program. The right has also argued that Medicare needs to be replaced with a voucher system because it is going broke. It turns out that both of these claims are absurdly false. While this report is bad news for those Republicans who are trying to sell privatization, it is also bad news for President Obama. The president has made the argument in the past that cost of living adjustments need to be cut by moving to a chained CPI. Today’s report illustrates that there is no need for impulsive steps in the name of getting a deal on entitlements.

It would be foolish to suggest that Medicare and Social Security are fine. There is still a long term systemic problem looming. Some action will have to be taken in order to shore up the two beloved programs. However, there is a huge difference between tweaking the programs and what Republicans want to do. Contrary to what Republicans have been selling, there is no need to gut and privatize the programs. Social Security isn’t going broke, and Medicare is not in immediate danger.

There is one simple solution out there that could keep Social Security strong for decades to come. The cap on the payroll tax should be raised or eliminated so that the wealthy are paying their fair share into the Social Security Trust Fund. As long as millionaires and billionaires continue to pay payroll tax only on the first $113,700 that they earn, Social Security will always be just a decade or two away from crisis.

Senate Democrats are on the record as opposing any cuts to Social Security, and today’s report should strengthen their opposition. This hasn’t stopped Republicans from trying to spin the report by exaggerating the potential future problems, but their cries of privatize today, privatize tomorrow, privatize forever have been largely discredited.

Republicans may lie, but the numbers don’t.

Let’s bow our heads in a brief moment of silence for the newest deceased Republican talking point, because Social Security isn’t going broke.

Jason Easley

Jason is the managing editor. He is also a White House Press Pool and a Congressional correspondent for PoliticusUSA. Jason has a Bachelor’s Degree in Political Science. His graduate work focused on public policy, with a specialization in social reform movements.

Awards and  Professional Memberships

Member of the Society of Professional Journalists and The American Political Science Association